Hot pastrami or a classic reuben—your choice depends on what fits your budget at this deli counter. Checking the Atlantic Deli Menu with Prices before you order is the smartest way to avoid sticker shock at the register. This guide breaks down the current costs so you can plan your meal without guessing.
Atlantic Deli is known for generous portions and classic New York-style sandwiches. But prices change, and you need the real numbers. Below, we cover the most popular items, from breakfast to late-night platters.
Atlantic Deli Menu With Prices
We have organized the menu by category to make your decision easier. Keep in mind that prices may vary slightly depending on the location or delivery service you use. Always confirm the final price at checkout.
Breakfast Selections
Mornings start early here, and the breakfast menu is served all day. You can build your own plate or grab a quick sandwich.
- Egg and Cheese Sandwich – $4.99
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese – $6.49
- Western Omelette Platter – $11.99 (includes home fries and toast)
- Buttermilk Pancakes (3 pieces) – $8.79
- Bagel with Cream Cheese – $2.79
Add a side of crispy hash browns for just $2.49. Coffee is refillable if you dine in.
Signature Hot Sandwiches
This is the heart of the menu. The hot sandwiches are piled high and served on fresh rye or roll. You pick the bread, they handle the rest.
- Hot Pastrami on Rye – $14.99
- Corned Beef Reuben – $15.49
- Turkey Club Sandwich – $13.29
- Chicken Cutlet Hero – $12.99
- Meatball Parmigiana Hero – $13.49
Each sandwich comes with a pickle spear and your choice of coleslaw or potato salad. Upgrading to fries costs an extra $1.50.
Cold Subs And Wraps
If you prefer something lighter, the cold section offers plenty of variety. The bread is always soft and baked daily.
- Italian Combo Sub – $12.49
- Turkey and Swiss Wrap – $10.99
- Tuna Salad Sandwich – $9.79
- BLT on White Toast – $10.29
You can add avocado to any cold sandwich for $1.25. Extra cheese is $0.75 per slice.
Salads And Sides
For a lighter bite, check the salad bowls. They are large enough for a full meal.
- Garden Salad – $8.99
- Caesar Salad with Chicken – $12.49
- Greek Salad with Feta – $11.29
- Macaroni Salad (small) – $3.49
Side orders of fries, onion rings, or sweet potato fries are all $4.29. Soup of the day is $5.99 with a bread roll.
Combo Deals And Platters
Look for the numbered combo specials on the board. These offer the best value for your money.
- Combo #1: Half Sandwich with Soup – $11.49
- Combo #2: Full Sandwich with Fries and Drink – $16.99
- Combo #3: 2 Slices of Pizza with a Salad – $10.79
These combos change weekly, so ask the cashier for today’s specific offerings. The prices listed here are the standard baseline.
Beverages And Desserts
Finish your meal with a drink or a sweet treat. The fountain drinks are large and come with free refills.
- Can Soda – $1.99
- Bottled Water – $2.29
- Fresh Lemonade – $3.49
- Cheesecake Slice – $5.99
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $1.79
Milkshakes are available in vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry for $6.49. They are thick and made to order.
One thing to note is that the menu prices at the counter might be slightly lower than what you see on third-party delivery apps. That is because those apps add a service fee. If you want the true Atlantic Deli menu with prices, it is best to call ahead or check their official website directly.
We recomend checking the daily specials board when you walk in. Sometimes they offer a smaller portion of the pastrami for a lower price. That is a great way to save a few bucks if you are not super hungry.
Also, the deli often runs a lunch special between 11 AM and 3 PM on weekdays. This special usually includes a smaller sandwich, a side, and a drink for around $10.99. Its not always advertised online, so asking at the counter is the best move.
In conclusion, the prices here are fair for the portion sizes you receive. A full meal with a drink and a side will likely cost you between $15 and $20 per person. For that price, you get enough food for two meals if you save half for later.
Take a moment to review the menu board before you order. That way, you can stay within your budget and still enjoy a fantastic deli meal. Remember to check the exact Atlantic Deli Menu with Prices at your local branch, as they might differ slightly from the ones listed above.