Your regular pizza order changes when you can compare the cost of large versus extra-large sizes on the menu. Before you call in, you need a clear look at the Anthonys Pizza Menu with Prices to make the smartest choice for your group and your wallet.
This guide breaks down the current offerings, portion sizes, and the exact cost of popular items. You will know what to expect before you dial, so there are no surprises at the register.
Anthonys Pizza Menu With Prices
Prices can shift slightly based on location, but these figures reflect the standard menu rates. Always confirm the total when you order, because delivery fees and taxes are added separately.
Classic Pies And Specialty Options
The core menu focuses on hand-tossed crust and a sweet tomato sauce. You can pick a plain cheese or load it with toppings.
- Small Cheese Pizza (10″) – $8.99
- Medium Cheese Pizza (12″) – $11.49
- Large Cheese Pizza (14″) – $13.99
- Extra-Large Cheese Pizza (16″) – $16.49
- Pepperoni Large (14″) – $15.99
- Supreme Large (14″) – $18.49
- BBQ Chicken Large (14″) – $17.99
You save roughly two dollars when you size up from a large to an extra-large. That is a solid deal for feeding two extra people.
Toppings And Add-Ons
Each topping is priced per pizza, not per slice. You can mix as many as you like, but the price adds up fast.
- Extra Cheese – $2.00
- Pepperoni, Sausage, or Bacon – $1.75 each
- Mushrooms, Onions, or Peppers – $1.50 each
- Fresh Garlic or Pineapple – $1.25 each
If you order a specialty pizza, you cannot swap toppings without an upcharge. Keep that in mind when you build your own.
Wings, Sides, And Salads
You do not have to stop at pizza. The sides are useful for rounding out a meal, and the portions are generous.
- Plain Wings (6 pcs) – $7.99
- Boneless Wings (8 pcs) – $8.49
- Garlic Knots (8 pcs) – $5.99
- Breadsticks with Marinara – $4.99
- Garden Salad – $6.49
- Caesar Salad – $6.99
The wings come with ranch or blue cheese at no extra cost. You can ask for extra sauce packets, but they might charge fifty cents per cup.
Desserts And Drinks
Finish the meal with something sweet. The dessert menu is short but reliable.
- Chocolate Lava Cake – $4.49
- Cinnamon Knots – $5.49
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.29
- Bottled Water – $1.99
You can also grab a cannoli for $3.99 if they have it in stock. That item sells out quick on weekends.
How To Order For The Best Value
Follow these steps to keep your total low without sacrificing taste.
- Compare the large and extra-large price difference first.
- Check if the location runs a two-topping Tuesday special.
- Skip the bottled soda and order a 2-liter instead.
- Ask for the lunch special if you order before 3 PM.
- Use the loyalty card if you visit more than once a month.
Most locations offer a pickup discount of about ten percent. That alone can cover the cost of a dessert.
Final Thoughts On The Menu
The menu is straightforward, and the prices are fair for the portion sizes. You should always call ahead to verify the daily special, because the deals change often.
One last note: the extra-large pizza is the best cost-per-slice option on the board. If you are feeding three or more people, do not settle for the large.
Keep this guide handy for your next order. You will save money and avoid the guesswork when you know the exact numbers before you pick up the phone.