Picking the right seafood spot along the coast starts with comparing what Anthony’s Fish Grotto charges for its signature catches and classic sides. You want fresh portions and fair prices, and the Anthonys Fish Grotto Menu with Prices is the first thing to check before you head out the door. Let’s break down the current offerings so you know exactly what to expect when you sit down.
This guide covers the main dishes, combo plates, and kid options. We also point out which items give you the best value for your money. No fluff, just the details you need for a solid meal plan.
Anthonys Fish Grotto Menu With Prices
Anthony’s keeps things simple with a focus on fried seafood and hearty sides. You will find a few grilled choices too, but the crispy batter is the house specialty. Below is the breakdown of the primary categories and their cost ranges.
Signature Fried Platters
These are the core meals that most regulars order. Each platter comes with your choice of two sides, usually fries, coleslaw, or a baked potato.
- Fish and Chips (2 pieces) – $13.95
- Fish and Chips (3 pieces) – $16.50
- Shrimp Platter (8 large shrimp) – $17.25
- Oyster Platter (12 oysters) – $18.75
- Scallop Platter (10 scallops) – $19.50
- Combo Platter (fish, shrimp, and oyster) – $21.95
Prices do not include tax or tip. They also change slightly during peak summer months, so ask your server for the daily special board.
Grilled And Lighter Options
If you are avoiding the fryer, there are a few grilled proteins available. They are a bit pricier because the prep takes longer.
- Grilled Salmon Fillet – $18.95
- Grilled Halibut – $22.50
- Grilled Shrimp Skewer – $16.95
All grilled meals come with a side salad instead of fries unless you request otherwise. That swap is free of charge.
Baskets And Sandwiches
For a quicker bite, the baskets are served in a paper-lined basket with a smaller portion of fries. Sandwiches are served on a toasted brioche bun.
- Fish Sandwich – $11.50
- Shrimp Po’ Boy – $13.25
- Clam Strip Basket – $12.75
- Fish Taco Basket (2 tacos) – $12.95
The fish taco basket is a sleeper hit. It comes with a chipotle crema that adds a nice kick without overpowering the fish.
Kids Menu And Sides
For younger eaters, the portions are smaller and the prices are friendlier. Each kids meal includes a small drink.
- Kids Fish Sticks – $7.50
- Kids Popcorn Shrimp – $8.25
- Kids Grilled Cheese – $6.95
Extra sides are available for order. A single side of fries or coleslaw costs $3.25. Extra tartar sauce or cocktail sauce is $0.75 per cup.
Drinks And Desserts
Beverage prices are standard for the area. Soft drinks run $2.95 and come with free refills. Iced tea is also $2.95. For dessert, the key lime pie is the most popular choice at $5.50 per slice.
How To Save Money Here
You can lower your bill without skipping the good stuff. Follow these simple steps.
- Visit before 5 PM on weekdays for the early bird special, which shaves $2 off most platters.
- Skip the combo platter if you are not very hungry. The 2-piece fish and chips is enough for most adults.
- Ask for water instead of soda. You save almost $3 per person.
- Share a dessert. The slices are large enough for two people.
When To Go For The Freshest Catch
Delivery trucks arrive on Tuesday and Friday mornings. If you want the best texture and flavor, go on those days. The fish is noticeably fresher and the portions look larger because they have not been sitting in the fridge.
Weekend evenings are the busiest. Expect a 20 to 30 minute wait if you arrive after 6 PM. Go early or late to avoid the rush.
Final Thoughts On Pricing
Overall, the prices at Anthony’s sit in the mid-range for coastal seafood. You are not paying fine dining prices, but you are also not getting bargain fast food. The quality of the batter and the generous portion sizes justify the cost for most visitors.
One last tip. Check the printed menu at the table before ordering. Sometimes they run a weekly special on the fried clam strips that is not listed on the online version. That special is usually a steal at $14.95 for a full platter.
So now you have the full picture of the Anthonys Fish Grotto menu with prices. Grab your wallet, pick a quiet weekday afternoon, and enjoy a solid seafood meal without any surprises on the bill. The staff is friendly and the food comes out hot, so you are in good hands.