Neighborhood pizzerias succeed when regulars can order without checking prices, and Anna Marias has earned that level of trust through consistency. But if you are new to the block, you still need to see the Anna Marias Pizzeria Menu with Prices before you call in that large pepperoni. Knowing the cost upfront helps you plan a quick lunch or a family dinner without any surprise at the register.
This guide breaks down the current offerings, portion sizes, and what each item will actually set you back. We have kept the details practical so you can decide what to order in under two minutes.
Anna Marias Pizzeria Menu With Prices
Below is the standard pricing structure for pies, slices, and sides. These prices reflect the regular menu and do not include delivery fees or local taxes. Always confirm the total when you call, as specials change on weekdays.
Classic Round Pizzas
Every pie uses the same house dough and slow-fermented sauce. You can choose between hand-tossed or thin crust at no extra charge.
- Small 12-inch Cheese – $10.50
- Medium 16-inch Cheese – $14.75
- Large 18-inch Cheese – $17.95
- X-Large 20-inch Cheese – $21.25
Toppings on a medium run about $2.10 each. Premium toppings like chicken or meatballs are $2.75. The exact Anna Marias Pizzeria Menu with Prices for specialty pies is listed below.
Specialty Pies
These are the pre-set combinations that the counter staff recommends. They are usually ready in about fifteen minutes.
- The Maria (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom) – $19.50 (large)
- Garden Fresh (onion, green pepper, tomato, black olive) – $18.75 (large)
- BBQ Chicken (grilled chicken, red onion, BBQ swirl) – $21.90 (large)
- White Pie (ricotta, garlic, mozzarella, no sauce) – $19.25 (large)
By The Slice
If you are eating solo, the slice counter is open until closing. Slices are reheated in the deck oven, not the microwave.
- Cheese Slice – $3.25
- Pepperoni Slice – $3.75
- Specialty Slice – $4.25
You can get two slices and a canned soda for $8.50, which is the best lunch deal on the block.
Appetizers And Sides
These sides pair well with a pie but are also filling enough for a light meal.
- Garlic Knots (8 pieces) – $5.50
- Breadsticks with marinara – $4.75
- Chicken Wings (6 pieces) – $8.95
- House Salad (small) – $6.25 / (large) – $9.75
Desserts And Drinks
Keep it simple. The dessert case changes daily, but these staples are always there.
- Canoli (1 piece) – $3.50
- Tiramisu cup – $4.95
- 2-Liter Soda – $3.99
- Bottled Water – $1.50
How To Order For Pickup
Calling ahead is still the fastest route. The phone line opens at 10:30 AM. If you order during the Friday night rush, expect a 25 to 35 minute wait.
- Decide on your crust type and size.
- Pick your toppings or choose a specialty pie.
- Ask for the current special, sometimes they have a large two-topping for $16.99.
- Give your name and pickup time.
Payment And Coupon Notes
Anna Marias accepts cash, Visa, Mastercard, and local debit cards. They do not take Amex. There is no charge for splitting a payment. The menu prices listed here have not changed since last spring, but the owner does adjust for wholesale cheese costs. If a price seems off, just ask the cashier to confirm before you pay.
One last tip: the X-Large pie is often the better value if you are feeding three or more people. The price per slice drops significantly compared to buying individual slices. Keep this page handy for your next order, and you will know exactly what to expect when you walk in.