Regulars at Andy’s Sandwich Shoppe know that the secret is in the bread, and the menu prices show that quality ingredients don’t have to cost extra. If you are searching for the Andys Sandwich Shoppe Menu with Prices before you head out the door, you have come to the right place. This guide breaks down the costs, the portions, and the best values so you can order with confidence.
Andys Sandwich Shoppe Menu With Prices
Let’s get straight to the numbers. The menu is pretty straightforward, but the options can feel overwhelming if it is your first visit. Below is the full breakdown of the classic offerings, updated for the current season.
Classic Hot Sandwiches
These are the heavy hitters. They come served on fresh-baked bread that holds up well against the sauces and juices.
- Italian Beef (Regular) – $8.99
- Italian Beef (Combo with Fries) – $11.49
- Meatball Marinara – $8.49
- Chicken Parmigiana – $9.29
- Philly Cheesesteak – $9.99
Cold Cut Specials
If you prefer a cooler bite, these are stacked high. They do not skimp on the turkey or ham here.
- Turkey & Swiss – $7.79
- Ham & Provolone – $7.49
- Club Sandwich (Triple Decker) – $10.29
- Tuna Salad – $6.99
Sides And Extras
No sandwich is complete without a side. The fries are cut in-house daily.
- Hand-Cut Fries – $3.29
- Onion Rings – $4.19
- Side Salad – $3.99
- Extra Meat Portion – $3.50
Drinks And Desserts
They serve standard fountain drinks and a few local bottled sodas. For dessert, the chocolate chip cookie is the move.
- Fountain Drink (Medium) – $1.89
- Bottled Soda – $2.29
- Fresh Baked Cookie – $1.49
How To Save Money On Your Order
You can get the best deal if you know how to navigate the menu. Here are a few tips that the staff will not always tell you.
Look For The Lunch Combo
Between 11:00 AM and 2:00 PM on weekdays, you can get a half sandwich with a cup of soup or a small salad for a reduced price. This is usually around $7.99, which is a steal compared to the full-size portions.
Ask For The “Ugly” Bread
At the end of the day, they sometimes have misshapen loaves that are not suitable for the display case. You can ask if they have any “ugly” bread available. They often sell these sandwiches at a dollar off, just to clear the inventory.
Skip The Combo, Buy The Extras
If you are really hungry, it is often cheaper to buy the sandwich alone and then order a side of extra meat. The combo upcharge is usually $2.50, but the extra meat is only $3.50. You get more protein for just a dollar more than the combo price.
Ordering Tips For First Timers
There is a specific flow to ordering here. Do not walk up and stare at the board for five minutes; the line moves fast. Here is the step-by-step process.
- Decide on hot or cold before you reach the register.
- Tell the cashier your bread choice (white, wheat, or rye).
- Specify if you want it “dipped” (for hot sandwiches) or “dry”.
- Pay at the counter and grab your number.
One common mistake is forgetting to ask for the peppers. The giardiniera is on the counter, but the sweet peppers are kept behind the register. Just ask for them on the side. Also, the prices listed above are pre-tax, so keep a little extra cash or change ready. The service is fast, but the shop can get crowded right at noon, so try to arrive before 11:45 AM if you want a seat by the window. The menu is simple, but the quality is consistent, which is why the locals keep coming back week after week.