At Amish Market East Menu with Prices, the menu with prices reads like a handwritten letter from Lancaster County, promising generous portions and honest cooking. You won’t find flashy graphics or complicated descriptions here. Instead, you get straightforward food that fills you up without emptying your wallet. This guide breaks down what you can expect to spend on your next visit, from breakfast to dinner.
Before you go, it helps to know that prices can shift slightly with the seasons. The market operates on a cash-friendly basis, though most vendors now accept cards. Bring a little extra cash anyway for the smaller bakeries.
Amish Market East Menu With Prices
This breakdown reflects typical costs observed over the last few months. Your final total will depend on the specific vendor you choose, as the market hosts several independent stands.
Breakfast Options And Costs
Morning meals are simple and hearty. You can grab a quick bite or sit down for a full plate.
- Scrapple and eggs: $7.50
- Pancake stack with syrup: $6.25
- Breakfast sandwich (egg, cheese, ham): $5.00
- Fresh-baked cinnamon roll: $3.75
- Large coffee or tea: $2.25
Lunch Favorites And Sandwiches
The deli counters are the busiest spots around noon. Sandwiches are piled high with fresh-cut meats.
- Roast beef and provolone hoagie: $9.95
- Chicken salad croissant: $8.50
- Grilled cheese with tomato soup: $7.25
- Turkey club on rye: $9.00
- Side of macaroni salad: $2.50
Hearty Dinner Plates
If you visit later in the day, look for the hot food counter. The offerings change daily but often include pot roast or baked chicken.
- Amish pot roast with mashed potatoes: $12.75
- Baked chicken and stuffing: $11.50
- Meatloaf with green beans: $10.95
- Ham steak with pineapple glaze: $11.00
- Vegetable lasagna (Friday only): $9.75
Bakery And Dessert Pricing
No trip is complete without a stop at the bakery case. The sugar cookies are a local legend.
- Whoopie pie (chocolate or pumpkin): $3.50
- Single slice of shoofly pie: $4.25
- Dozen sugar cookies: $8.00
- Apple dumpling with cinnamon sauce: $5.50
- Loaf of fresh white bread: $3.95
Bulk Foods And Grocery Items
You can also stock your pantry while you are there. The bulk bins offer good value for staples.
- Rolled oats (per pound): $1.89
- Popcorn kernels (per pound): $2.10
- Local honey (16 oz jar): $7.25
- Amish egg noodles (per pound): $3.40
- Smoked bacon (per pound): $6.80
Tips For Ordering Efficiently
Follow these steps to make your visit smoother, especially on a Saturday morning.
- Walk the full perimeter first to scout all the vendors.
- Write down your order on your phone before waiting in line.
- Ask for sauces and dressings on the side to keep bread crisp.
- Check the daily specials board for the best deals.
- Buy baked goods last so they don’t get squished in your bag.
One thing to note is that the market closes early on Wednesdays. Double-check the posted hours on the door before making a special trip. The staff are generally friendly but they move fast during the lunch rush, so have your payment ready.
Overall, the Amish Market East menu with prices offers solid value for the portion sizes. A family of four can eat well for around forty dollars if you skip the fancy drinks. The food is consistent, the service is quick, and the aromas alone are worth the visit. Just remember to bring your appetite and a little patience during peak hours. You will leave full, happy, and probably carrying a bag of those sugar cookies for the road.