Regulars know the counter at All Star Bagel fills up fast, and this price guide explains exactly why that first bite is worth the wait. You need the All Star Bagel Menu with Prices before you get in line, because the choices are plenty and the line moves quicker than you think. This guide breaks down the classics, the specialty schmears, and the combos so you can order with total confidence.
All Star Bagel isn’t just about a round dough with a hole. It is about the chew, the crust, and the generous hand with toppings. They boil their bagels daily, which gives them that signature shiny outside and dense inside. You will taste the difference from the first bite, and your wallet will appreciate the fair pricing too.
All Star Bagel Menu With Prices
Below is the current breakdown of the core menu items. Prices can shift slightly based on location or seasonal specials, but this snapshot reflects the standard costs you can expect to pay today. Always check the board for any daily specials that are not listed here.
Classic Bagels And Spreads
You cannot go wrong with the basics. They offer a wide rotation of flavors, but the staples are always available. Here is what you will pay for the foundation of your meal:
- Single Plain Bagel: $1.25
- Single Everything Bagel: $1.35
- Dozen Assorted Bagels: $12.50
- Half Dozen Bagels: $7.00
- Small Cream Cheese (Plain or Veggie): $1.50
- Large Cream Cheese Tub: $4.25
Signature Sandwiches And Melts
This is where the counter really shines. They load these up with fresh ingredients and hot fillings. If you are hungry, go for the full size. If you want a snack, ask for the half portion on any sandwich.
- Nova Lox Sandwich (Capers, Onion, Tomato): $11.95
- Bacon, Egg, and Cheese on a Roll: $6.75
- Turkey Avocado Club: $9.50
- Pastrami Melt with Swiss: $10.25
- Veggie Stack (Hummus, Cucumber, Sprouts): $8.00
Build Your Own Combo
If you want to save a little cash, you should consider the combo deal. It is the smartest way to get a drink and a side without paying full price. Here is how the pricing works for the combo:
- Pick any bagel with cream cheese.
- Choose a side (hash browns or fruit cup).
- Select a small coffee or fresh orange juice.
The total for this combo is $8.95. Adding extra meat or egg to the sandwich costs an additional $1.50 per item.
Coffee And Cold Drinks
They do not mess around with the drinks. The coffee is strong and always fresh. You can get a refill on drip coffee if you are dining in.
- Small Drip Coffee: $2.25
- Large Cold Brew: $3.75
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice: $4.50
- Assorted Bottled Sodas: $2.00
Tips For Ordering Faster
You should have your order ready when you reach the register. The staff is efficient, but they appreciate decisiveness. If you are ordering for a group, call ahead. They offer a 10% discount for bulk orders over 20 bagels, but you must request it specifically.
One thing to note: the prices listed above are pre-tax. Also, they only accept credit cards for orders over five dollars, so keep some cash on hand for small purchases. The line moves fast, but the bagels are worth every minute you wait. Now you know exactly what to order and what it will cost.