Summer afternoons at Alexs Grill call for something cold and sweet, and the Alexs Grill Ice Cream Menu with Prices makes choosing the hard part. You will find classic cones, thick shakes, and loaded sundaes that fit any budget.
Most people walk in for a burger but stay for the dessert counter. The menu is simple to read, and the staff are happy to give you a sample spoon if you are stuck between two flavors.
Alexs Grill Ice Cream Menu With Prices
Here is the full breakdown of what you can order today. Prices are current for the 2025 season, but they might change slightly with supply costs.
Classic Scoops And Cones
If you want a no-fuss treat, grab a scoop or two in a cup or a waffle cone. They use a local dairy brand that rotates seasonal specials every month.
- Single Scoop (Cup or Cake Cone) – $3.25
- Double Scoop (Cup or Cake Cone) – $4.75
- Waffle Cone Upgrade – $1.00 extra
- Kid’s Mini Scoop – $2.00
The waffle cones are made fresh every morning. You can smell them from the parking lot, which is a nice touch.
Hand-Spun Milkshakes
These shakes are thick enough that you might need to wait a minute for them to soften. Each one comes with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
- Vanilla, Chocolate, or Strawberry – $5.50
- Cookies and Cream – $6.25
- Peanut Butter Cup – $6.75
- Mint Chocolate Chip – $6.25
- Add a Shot of Espresso – $1.50
You can also ask for a “split shake” where they layer two flavors in the same cup. It does not cost extra, which is a solid deal.
Loaded Sundaes
Sundaes are served in a chilled metal dish. That keeps the ice cream from melting too fast while you eat.
- Hot Fudge Sundae – $5.95
- Caramel Pecan Sundae – $6.50
- Banana Split – $7.25
- Brownie Bottom Sundae – $7.00
- Strawberry Shortcake Sundae – $6.75
Every sundae comes with your choice of soft serve or hand-dipped ice cream. The brownie bottom is the most popular item on the whole menu, so expect a short wait if you order it during peak hours.
Ice Cream Sandwiches And Novelty Items
For something you can hold with one hand, try the pressed sandwiches. They use fresh-baked cookies that are still warm when you order.
- Classic Chocolate Chip Sandwich – $4.50
- Double Chocolate Sandwich – $4.75
- Seasonal Fruit Pop – $3.00
- Ice Cream Float (Root Beer or Cola) – $4.95
The floats are a hidden gem. They use a full scoop of vanilla and pour the soda right in front of you so you get that foamy head.
Toppings And Extras
You can customize almost anything on the menu. Here is the price list for add-ons.
- Hot Fudge, Caramel, or Strawberry Sauce – $0.75 each
- Whipped Cream – $0.50
- Chopped Nuts – $0.75
- Sprinkles – $0.25
- Cherry – $0.25
Pro tip: the sauces are house-made and slightly thicker than store-bought versions. If you like a lot of topping, order a “wet” sundae and they will double the sauce for a dollar.
Daily Specials And Combos
Tuesday is half-price shake day after 3 PM. Thursday features a free waffle cone upgrade with any double scoop purchase.
They also have a combo deal where you get a single scoop and a small drink for $4.25. It is not listed on the main board, so you have to ask for it at the register.
One thing to note: the grill gets busy around 6 PM. If you want a quiet experience, go right when they open at 11 AM. The ice cream case is fully stocked at that time, and you wont have to wait behind a line of families.
That is the complete Alexs Grill Ice Cream Menu with Prices. Bring cash if you can, because the card reader sometimes goes down on hot weekends. And if you are torn between two flavors, just get the double scoop. You will not regret it.