Peter Luger in New York serves steak dinners with their famous bacon appetizer, and the menu prices reflect the quality of aged beef. If you are planning a visit to this iconic Brooklyn steakhouse, you likely want to know exactly what you will pay. The Peter Luger New York menu prices can be a surprise for first-timers, but the experience is worth every dollar.
This article breaks down everything you need to know about the costs. We will cover steaks, sides, appetizers, desserts, and drinks. You will also get tips on how to save money and what to expect from the service.
Peter Luger New York Menu Prices Overview
Peter Luger is not a cheap restaurant. The prices are high because the beef is dry-aged in-house for at least 28 days. The menu is simple, with only a few steak cuts and classic sides. Here is a quick look at what you will spend.
- Steak for one person: $55 to $70
- Steak for two: $110 to $140
- Famous bacon appetizer: $16 to $20
- Sides like creamed spinach: $10 to $14
- Desserts like cheesecake: $10 to $12
These prices can change slightly based on market conditions. Always check the current menu before you go. The restaurant does not accept credit cards, only cash or a Peter Luger debit card.
Steak Cuts And Their Prices
The star of the menu is the steak. Peter Luger offers only a few cuts, but each one is perfectly aged and cooked. The most popular is the Porterhouse, which comes in sizes for one, two, three, or four people.
Porterhouse Steak
This is the signature dish. The Porterhouse includes both a strip steak and a tenderloin filet. It is served sliced, sizzling in butter, and topped with a secret sauce. Prices vary by size.
- Porterhouse for one: $58.95
- Porterhouse for two: $117.90
- Porterhouse for three: $176.85
- Porterhouse for four: $235.80
These prices are for the steak only. Sides and appetizers are extra. The portion for two is usually enough for two hungry adults, but you might want extra sides.
Steak For One
If you are dining alone, you can order a smaller cut. The steak for one is a New York strip or a filet mignon. It is not as famous as the Porterhouse, but it is still excellent.
- Steak for one (New York strip): $54.95
- Steak for one (filet mignon): $59.95
These cuts are cooked to order, usually medium-rare. The steak for one is a good option if you want a quick meal without leftovers.
Porterhouse For Two With Sides
Many people order the Porterhouse for two and share sides. This is the classic Peter Luger experience. The total cost for two people with sides and drinks can easily reach $200 or more.
- Porterhouse for two: $117.90
- Creamed spinach: $11.95
- German fried potatoes: $11.95
- Bacon appetizer: $18.95
- Two drinks: $20 to $30
Total for two people: around $180 to $200. This does not include tax or tip. The tip is usually 20% because the service is excellent.
Appetizers And Their Prices
The appetizers at Peter Luger are almost as famous as the steak. The bacon is a must-try. It is thick-cut, smoked, and served with a sweet glaze. Other appetizers include shrimp cocktail and tomato juice.
Famous Bacon
This is the most popular starter. The bacon is thick, crispy, and sweet. It is served as a single slice or a double order. Many people order it for the table.
- Single order of bacon: $18.95
- Double order of bacon: $37.90
The bacon is enough for one person per slice. If you are sharing, order one slice per person. It is rich and filling, so do not over-order.
Shrimp Cocktail
The shrimp cocktail is a classic starter. The shrimp are large, cold, and served with a tangy cocktail sauce. It is a lighter option before the heavy steak.
- Shrimp cocktail (4 pieces): $16.95
- Shrimp cocktail (6 pieces): $23.95
This is a good choice if you want something fresh. The sauce is house-made and has a nice kick.
Tomato Juice
This is a simple appetizer, but it is popular. The tomato juice is served cold with a celery stick. It is a refreshing start to the meal.
- Tomato juice: $6.95
It is not a big portion, but it is a nice palate cleanser. Some people order it as a drink instead of alcohol.
Sides And Their Prices
Sides are served family-style. You order them separately and share with the table. The portions are generous, so one side can feed two or three people. The most popular sides are creamed spinach and German fried potatoes.
Creamed Spinach
This is the most famous side. The spinach is cooked with cream and a touch of nutmeg. It is rich, creamy, and pairs perfectly with the steak.
- Creamed spinach: $11.95
One order is enough for two people. If you have a larger group, order two. It is a classic side that you should not skip.
German Fried Potatoes
These are sliced potatoes fried with onions and bacon. They are crispy on the outside and soft inside. They are a hearty side that complements the steak.
- German fried potatoes: $11.95
One order feeds two to three people. They are very filling, so do not order too many sides. The potatoes are a favorite among regulars.
Other Sides
Peter Luger also offers a few other sides. These include onion rings, baked potato, and asparagus. They are all good, but not as famous as the spinach and potatoes.
- Onion rings: $10.95
- Baked potato: $9.95
- Asparagus (seasonal): $12.95
These sides are simple but well-prepared. The onion rings are crispy and not greasy. The baked potato is huge and comes with butter and sour cream.
Desserts And Their Prices
After a heavy steak dinner, you might think you are too full for dessert. But the desserts at Peter Luger are worth saving room for. The most famous is the cheesecake, but there are other options too.
Cheesecake
The cheesecake is New York-style. It is dense, creamy, and served with a berry sauce. It is a classic ending to the meal.
- Cheesecake: $11.95
One slice is enough for two people to share. It is very rich, so you might not want a whole slice to yourself.
Chocolate Mousse
The chocolate mousse is light and airy. It is served in a tall glass with whipped cream. It is a good choice if you want something less heavy than cheesecake.
- Chocolate mousse: $10.95
This is a popular dessert for chocolate lovers. It is not too sweet, and the texture is perfect.
Ice Cream And Sorbet
Peter Luger offers a few ice cream and sorbet options. These are simple but refreshing. The flavors change seasonally.
- Ice cream (two scoops): $9.95
- Sorbet (two scoops): $9.95
These are good if you want a light dessert. The sorbet is especially refreshing after a heavy meal.
Drinks And Their Prices
Peter Luger has a full bar. You can order beer, wine, cocktails, and non-alcoholic drinks. The drink prices are reasonable for a high-end steakhouse.
Beer
The beer list includes domestic and imported options. You can get bottles or drafts. The most popular is the Peter Luger beer, which is a lager brewed exclusively for the restaurant.
- Domestic beer (bottle): $7.95
- Imported beer (bottle): $9.95
- Peter Luger beer (draft): $8.95
The Peter Luger beer is light and crisp. It pairs well with the steak. You can also order a pitcher for the table.
Wine
The wine list is extensive. It focuses on red wines that pair well with steak. You can order by the glass or by the bottle. Prices start around $12 per glass.
- Glass of red wine: $12 to $18
- Bottle of red wine: $45 to $200
If you are not sure what to order, ask the sommelier. They can recommend a wine that fits your budget and tastes.
Cocktails
The cocktail menu is small but classic. You can order a martini, old fashioned, or Manhattan. These are strong and well-made.
- Martini: $14.95
- Old fashioned: $15.95
- Manhattan: $15.95
These cocktails are perfect before or during dinner. They are not too sweet and complement the steak.
Non-Alcoholic Drinks
If you do not drink alcohol, there are plenty of options. You can order soda, juice, or coffee. The prices are reasonable.
- Soda: $3.95
- Juice: $4.95
- Coffee: $4.95
The coffee is strong and fresh. It is a good way to end the meal, especially if you order dessert.
How To Save Money At Peter Luger
Peter Luger is expensive, but there are ways to save money. You do not have to order the most expensive items. Here are some tips to keep your bill lower.
- Share a steak. The Porterhouse for two is cheaper per person than ordering two individual steaks.
- Skip the appetizers. The bacon is amazing, but it adds $20 to your bill. If you are on a budget, skip it.
- Order fewer sides. One side can feed two people. Do not order a side for each person.
- Drink water. Alcoholic drinks add up fast. Stick with water or soda to save money.
- Go for lunch. Lunch prices are slightly lower than dinner prices. The menu is the same, but the portions might be smaller.
- Use cash. Peter Luger does not accept credit cards. If you use a debit card, there is a fee. Bring cash to avoid extra charges.
These tips can save you $20 to $50 per person. The experience is still the same, but your wallet will thank you.
What To Expect From The Service
The service at Peter Luger is old-school. The waiters are professional and efficient. They are not overly friendly, but they are attentive. You will get your food quickly, and they will check on you regularly.
The dress code is casual. You do not need to wear a suit or dress. Jeans and a nice shirt are fine. The atmosphere is lively and noisy, especially on weekends.
Reservations are required. You can book online or by phone. Walk-ins are rarely accepted, especially for dinner. Book at least two weeks in advance for a weekend table.
The restaurant has two locations: the original in Brooklyn and a second location in Long Island. The Brooklyn location is the original and has more history. The menu and prices are the same at both locations.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are The Current Peter Luger New York Menu Prices?
Prices change slightly over time. As of 2024, the Porterhouse for two is around $118. Sides are about $12 each. Appetizers range from $10 to $20. Always check the menu before you go.
Does Peter Luger Accept Credit Cards?
No, Peter Luger does not accept credit cards. They only accept cash or a Peter Luger debit card. There is an ATM inside the restaurant, but it charges a fee.
Is The Bacon At Peter Luger Worth The Price?
Yes, the bacon is a must-try. It is thick, smoky, and sweet. It is expensive at $19 for a single slice, but it is a unique appetizer that you will not find anywhere else.
Can I Order A Steak For One Person?
Yes, you can order a steak for one. The options are a New York strip or a filet mignon. These are smaller than the Porterhouse and cost around $55 to $60.
How Much Should I Tip At Peter Luger?
The standard tip is 20%. The service is excellent, so you should tip accordingly. Some people tip more if they had a special occasion.
Final Thoughts On Peter Luger New York Menu Prices
Peter Luger is a classic New York steakhouse. The prices are high, but the quality is unmatched. The Peter Luger New York menu prices reflect the care and time that goes into aging the beef. If you are a steak lover, this is a must-visit.
Plan ahead, bring cash, and be ready to spend. Share dishes to save money, and do not skip the bacon. The experience is worth the cost, and you will leave full and happy.
Remember to book your reservation early. The restaurant is always busy, especially on weekends. With a little planning, you can enjoy one of the best steaks in New York without breaking the bank.