Papa Gino’s Menu Prices

Papa Gino’s menu prices feature classic pizzas, pastas, and subs that have been New England favorites for decades. Whether you’re ordering for a family dinner or grabbing a quick lunch, knowing what you’ll pay helps you plan your meal. This guide breaks down every item on the menu with current prices, so you can order with confidence.

Papa Gino’s has been serving up Italian-American comfort food since 1961. Their menu focuses on thin-crust pizzas, hearty pasta bowls, and stacked subs. Prices vary slightly by location, but the ranges below are accurate for most stores in 2025.

Pizza Prices

Pizza is the star here. They offer three crust styles: Original Thin, Hand-Tossed, and Gluten-Free. Sizes range from personal (10-inch) to extra-large (16-inch).

Cheese Pizza (10-inch) – $9.99
Cheese Pizza (12-inch) – $12.49
Cheese Pizza (14-inch) – $14.99
Cheese Pizza (16-inch) – $17.49
Pepperoni Pizza (10-inch) – $10.99
Pepperoni Pizza (12-inch) – $13.49
Pepperoni Pizza (14-inch) – $15.99
Pepperoni Pizza (16-inch) – $18.49
Supreme Pizza (10-inch) – $12.49
Supreme Pizza (12-inch) – $14.99
Supreme Pizza (14-inch) – $17.99
Supreme Pizza (16-inch) – $20.99
Gluten-Free Cheese Pizza (10-inch) – $11.99
Gluten-Free Pepperoni Pizza (10-inch) – $12.99

You can build your own pizza too. Each topping costs extra: pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, and extra cheese are $1.50 each for small, $2.00 for medium, $2.50 for large, and $3.00 for extra-large.

Specialty Pizzas

These come pre-loaded with toppings and are fan favorites.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza (12-inch) – $14.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza (14-inch) – $17.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza (12-inch) – $14.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza (14-inch) – $17.99
Veggie Pizza (12-inch) – $13.99
Veggie Pizza (14-inch) – $16.99
Meat Lover’s Pizza (12-inch) – $15.99
Meat Lover’s Pizza (14-inch) – $18.99

Pasta Prices

Pasta dishes come with garlic bread. You can choose spaghetti, ziti, or whole wheat pasta.

Spaghetti with Marinara – $8.99
Spaghetti with Meatballs – $10.99
Baked Ziti – $9.99
Baked Ziti with Meatballs – $11.99
Chicken Parmesan Pasta – $12.99
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta – $11.99
Fettuccine Alfredo – $9.99
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken – $12.49
Lasagna – $11.49

Add a side salad to any pasta for $2.49 extra. The salads come with your choice of dressing: ranch, Italian, or balsamic.

Sub Prices

Subs are served on a toasted hoagie roll with lettuce, tomato, and onion. You can add cheese for $0.75.

Meatball Sub – $8.99
Italian Sub – $9.49
Chicken Parmesan Sub – $9.99
Eggplant Parmesan Sub – $8.99
Steak and Cheese Sub – $10.49
Buffalo Chicken Sub – $9.49
Turkey Sub – $8.49
Ham and Cheese Sub – $8.49

Subs come in two sizes: 6-inch and 12-inch. The prices above are for 12-inch. A 6-inch sub costs about $5.49 to $6.99 depending on the filling.

Salad Prices

Salads are fresh and come with dressing on the side.

Garden Salad – $5.99
Caesar Salad – $6.49
Grilled Chicken Salad – $8.49
Buffalo Chicken Salad – $8.99
Antipasto Salad – $8.49

Add a protein like grilled chicken or shrimp to any salad for $2.50.

Appetizers And Sides

Perfect for sharing or adding to your meal.

Garlic Bread – $3.49
Garlic Bread with Cheese – $4.49
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces) – $5.99
Onion Rings – $4.99
French Fries – $3.49
Chicken Tenders (4 pieces) – $6.49
Chicken Tenders (6 pieces) – $8.49
Buffalo Wings (6 pieces) – $7.99
Buffalo Wings (12 pieces) – $13.99

Dessert Prices

Finish your meal with something sweet.

Chocolate Chip Cookie – $1.99
Brownie – $2.49
Tiramisu – $3.99
Cannoli (2 pieces) – $3.49
Ice Cream Cup – $2.99

Drink Prices

Beverages are standard for a fast-casual restaurant.

Soft Drinks (20 oz) – $2.29
Soft Drinks (32 oz) – $2.79
Bottled Water – $1.99
Iced Tea – $2.29
Milk – $1.99
Juice Box – $1.49

Kids Menu Prices

Kids meals come with a drink and a small dessert.

Kids Cheese Pizza – $5.99
Kids Pepperoni Pizza – $6.49
Kids Spaghetti with Marinara – $5.49
Kids Chicken Tenders (2 pieces) – $5.99
Kids Mac and Cheese – $4.99

Combo Meals And Deals

Papa Gino’s offers several value combos that save you money.

Lunch Combo – $8.99 (includes a personal pizza or half sub, fries, and a drink)
Dinner Combo – $12.99 (includes a medium pizza or full sub, side salad, and a drink)
Family Meal Deal – $29.99 (includes a large pizza, a pasta dish, and a salad)
Party Pack – $39.99 (includes two large pizzas and a 2-liter soda)

These deals are available during specific hours. The lunch combo runs from 11 AM to 3 PM daily. The dinner combo starts at 4 PM.

How To Order And Save Money

You can order online, through the app, by phone, or in person. The app often has exclusive coupons.

Download the Papa Gino’s app from your app store.
Create an account with your email.
Check the “Offers” tab for current deals.
Place your order for pickup or delivery.
Use the promo code at checkout.

Signing up for their email list gives you a free appetizer on your next order. You’ll also get birthday rewards if you provide your birth date.

Another way to save is to order during off-peak hours. Lunch combos are cheaper than dinner items. Also, large pizzas cost less per slice than small ones. If you’re feeding a group, go with a 16-inch pizza instead of two 10-inch ones. You’ll pay about $5 less for more food.

Delivery Fees And Tipping

Delivery fees vary by location. Most stores charge $3.99 for delivery. Some locations have a minimum order of $10 for delivery. Tip your driver 15-20% of the total before fees.

If you pick up your order, you can skip the delivery fee entirely. That’s an easy way to save $4.

Nutritional Information

Papa Gino’s provides nutritional info on their website. A slice of cheese pizza (14-inch) has about 280 calories. A meatball sub has around 650 calories. The chicken Caesar salad has 420 calories without dressing.

If you’re watching carbs, the gluten-free pizza crust has 25 grams of carbs per slice. The regular thin crust has 22 grams. The hand-tossed crust has 30 grams.

Allergen Info

Common allergens include wheat, dairy, soy, and eggs. The gluten-free pizza is made in a shared kitchen, so it may contain traces of gluten. Always tell the staff about allergies when ordering.

You can request no cheese on any pizza or sub. They also offer vegan options like the garden salad without cheese and the marinara pasta.

Location Variations

Prices can differ by about $1-2 depending on the state. Massachusetts locations tend to be slightly higher than Rhode Island ones. Connecticut stores fall in between. The menu items themselves are the same across all locations.

Some stores have limited-time offers. For example, during football season, they might sell a “Game Day Special” with a large pizza and wings for $24.99. Check your local store’s website for these deals.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the current Papa Gino’s menu prices for 2025?

Prices range from $4.99 for kids meals to $20.99 for a large supreme pizza. Most items fall between $8 and $15. Check the sections above for full details.

Does Papa Gino’s have any gluten-free options?

Yes, they offer a gluten-free 10-inch cheese or pepperoni pizza. It costs $11.99 to $12.99. They also have gluten-free pasta available on request.

Can I get a discount on Papa Gino’s menu prices?

Yes, use the app for exclusive coupons, order lunch combos, or sign up for email rewards. Family meal deals also offer savings compared to buying items separately.

Are Papa Gino’s menu prices the same at all locations?

Prices vary slightly by location, usually by $1-2. The menu items are consistent across all New England stores.

What is the cheapest item on Papa Gino’s menu?

The kids mac and cheese at $4.99 is the cheapest item. Garlic bread at $3.49 is the cheapest side. A personal cheese pizza at $9.99 is the cheapest pizza.

Papa Gino’s menu prices are reasonable for the quality and portion sizes. A family of four can eat for under $40 with a large pizza and a pasta dish. The lunch combos are especially good value if you’re eating alone.

Remember to check the app before ordering. Sometimes they have buy-one-get-one deals on pizzas. Those can cut your bill in half. Also, if you order online, you can customize your items more easily than over the phone.

One thing to note: the prices listed here are base prices. Adding extra toppings, cheese, or premium ingredients will increase the cost. A fully loaded supreme pizza can cost up to $25 for a large size. But for most people, a standard cheese or pepperoni pizza is plenty.

The pasta dishes are filling and come with garlic bread. The baked ziti is a crowd-pleaser. The chicken parmesan pasta is a bit pricier but worth it for the portion size. You get a full breast of chicken breaded and fried, then topped with marinara and mozzarella.

Subs are stacked high with meat. The steak and cheese sub is especially popular. It comes with thinly sliced steak, melted provolone, and grilled onions and peppers. The meatball sub has three large meatballs smothered in marinara and cheese.

Salads are fresh but not huge. The grilled chicken salad is a good option if you want something lighter. The buffalo chicken salad has spicy tenders on top of mixed greens.

Appetizers are standard. The mozzarella sticks are crispy on the outside and gooey inside. The buffalo wings come with ranch or blue cheese dressing. The chicken tenders are breaded and fried, good for kids or adults.

Desserts are simple but satisfying. The tiramisu is a coffee-flavored Italian classic. The cannoli has a crispy shell with sweet ricotta filling. The brownie is fudgy and warm.

Drinks are typical for a pizza place. They have Coke products, iced tea, and water. No specialty drinks like smoothies or shakes.

Kids meals are affordable and come with a small dessert like a cookie or brownie. The kids pizza is a 6-inch size, perfect for young children.

Overall, Papa Gino’s offers good value for New England comfort food. The prices are competitive with other pizza chains in the region. If you’re looking for a quick, filling meal, this is a solid choice.

One final tip: always check for coupons before ordering. Papa Gino’s frequently runs promotions like “20% off your online order” or “free garlic bread with any pizza purchase.” These can save you a few dollars each time.

Now you have a complete picture of Papa Gino’s menu prices. Whether you want a simple cheese pizza or a full family feast, you know exactly what to expect. Go ahead and place your order with confidence.