Peter Luger’s menu prices reflect their century-old tradition of serving USDA Prime steaks in Brooklyn. If you’re planning a visit to this iconic steakhouse, understanding the Peter Luger Menu Prices is the first step to budgeting for a memorable meal. This guide breaks down every cost, from steaks to sides, so you know exactly what to expect.
Peter Luger has been a New York institution since 1887. The menu is famously simple, focusing on high-quality beef. But simplicity doesn’t mean cheap—prices here are premium. Let’s get straight to the numbers.
Peter Luger Menu Prices For Steaks
The star of the show is the steak. Peter Luger serves only USDA Prime beef, dry-aged on-site. Prices vary by cut and portion size. Here’s what you’ll pay for the main event.
Steak For One
If you’re dining solo, the steak for one is your best bet. It’s a generous portion, but not overwhelming.
- Peter Luger Steak (for one): $62.95
- Filet Mignon (10 oz): $59.95
- Porterhouse Steak (for one): $68.95
These prices include the signature sizzling butter sauce. No sides come with the steak, so factor those in separately.
Steak For Two
Most people order the steak for two. It’s the classic Peter Luger experience. The portion is large enough for two hungry eaters.
- Peter Luger Steak (for two): $124.95
- Porterhouse Steak (for two): $136.95
- Filet Mignon (for two, 20 oz): $118.95
Note that the steak for two is actually a single large cut, not two separate steaks. It’s served on a platter and carved tableside if you ask.
Steak For Three Or Four
Groups can order larger portions. These are ideal for sharing.
- Peter Luger Steak (for three): $186.95
- Porterhouse Steak (for three): $204.95
- Peter Luger Steak (for four): $248.95
- Porterhouse Steak (for four): $272.95
These prices are per person, but the steak is served as one massive cut. It’s a spectacle.
Appetizers And Sides: Peter Luger Menu Prices
Steaks are the main event, but the appetizers and sides are worth your attention. They’re simple but executed perfectly. Here’s what they cost.
Appetizers
Start your meal with one of these classics. Portions are generous, so share if you can.
- Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail: $22.95
- Bacon-Wrapped Scallops: $24.95
- Luger’s Original German Potato Pancake (with applesauce): $14.95
- Tomato and Onion Salad: $12.95
- Chopped Salad: $16.95
The shrimp cocktail is a standout. The shrimp are huge and perfectly chilled. The potato pancake is a nod to the restaurant’s German roots.
Sides
Sides are served family-style. They’re meant to be shared. Prices are per order, not per person.
- Creamed Spinach: $12.95
- German Fried Potatoes: $12.95
- Steakhouse Fries: $11.95
- Grilled Asparagus: $14.95
- Mushrooms in Cream Sauce: $13.95
- Onion Rings: $11.95
- Baked Potato: $9.95
The creamed spinach is a must-order. It’s rich, creamy, and pairs perfectly with the steak. The German fried potatoes are also a fan favorite.
Desserts And Drinks: Peter Luger Menu Prices
Don’t skip dessert. Peter Luger’s desserts are old-school and satisfying. Drinks are also worth noting, especially if you want a cocktail or wine.
Desserts
These are simple, classic desserts. No fancy plating, just great taste.
- Luger’s Cheesecake: $11.95
- Chocolate Mousse: $10.95
- Ice Cream (vanilla or chocolate): $8.95
- Apple Strudel: $11.95
The cheesecake is dense and creamy. The chocolate mousse is light and airy. Both are excellent choices.
Drinks
Peter Luger has a full bar. Beer, wine, and cocktails are available. Prices are typical for a high-end steakhouse.
- Draft Beer (pint): $8.95
- Bottled Beer: $7.95
- Glass of Wine (house): $14.95
- Signature Cocktail (e.g., Old Fashioned): $18.95
- Soft Drinks: $4.95
- Coffee or Tea: $5.95
Wine by the bottle starts around $50 and goes up significantly. The sommelier can help you choose.
How To Save Money On Peter Luger Menu Prices
Peter Luger is expensive, but there are ways to keep costs down. Here are some practical tips.
Share Everything
Portions are huge. Two people can easily share a steak for two and one side. You don’t need a side per person.
Skip The Appetizer
If you’re on a budget, skip the appetizer. The steak is filling enough. You can always add a side.
Go For Lunch
Lunch prices are the same as dinner. But lunch portions are slightly smaller, so you might save by ordering a steak for one instead of for two.
Bring Cash
Peter Luger does not accept credit cards. They only take cash or their own debit card. This can help you stick to a budget if you bring only what you plan to spend.
Order The Burger
If you’re really on a budget, try the Peter Luger Burger. It’s only available at lunch and costs $19.95. It’s made from the same dry-aged beef trimmings.
Peter Luger Menu Prices: What To Expect For A Full Meal
Let’s break down a typical meal cost. This will help you plan your budget.
Dinner For Two
A standard dinner for two might look like this:
- Steak for two: $136.95
- Creamed Spinach: $12.95
- German Fried Potatoes: $12.95
- Two glasses of wine: $29.90
- Cheesecake: $11.95
Total before tax and tip: $203.70. With tax and a 20% tip, you’re looking at around $270.
Dinner For Four
For a group of four, a typical meal might be:
- Steak for four: $272.95
- Two sides: $25.90
- Two appetizers: $45.90
- Four glasses of wine: $59.80
- Two desserts: $23.90
Total before tax and tip: $428.45. With tax and tip, expect to pay around $570.
These are rough estimates. Your actual bill may vary based on what you order.
Peter Luger Menu Prices: Location Differences
Peter Luger has two locations: Brooklyn and Great Neck, Long Island. Prices are the same at both. The menu is identical. No difference in cost.
However, the Brooklyn location is the original and more famous. It’s cash-only. The Great Neck location accepts credit cards, but there’s a 3% surcharge.
Peter Luger Menu Prices: Historical Changes
Prices have gone up over the years. In 2010, a steak for two was around $85. Now it’s $136.95. That’s about a 60% increase in 14 years.
Inflation and rising beef costs are the main reasons. Peter Luger sources only USDA Prime beef, which is expensive. The dry-aging process also adds cost.
Despite the increases, demand remains high. Reservations are still hard to get, especially on weekends.
Frequently Asked Questions About Peter Luger Menu Prices
Here are common questions people have about costs at Peter Luger.
Is Peter Luger Expensive?
Yes, it’s a high-end steakhouse. Expect to spend $100–$150 per person for a full meal with drinks.
Does Peter Luger Have A Dress Code?
No official dress code, but most people dress smart casual. No shorts or flip-flops, though.
Can I Get A Doggy Bag?
Yes, they’ll wrap up leftovers. The portions are large, so you’ll likely have some.
Are There Vegetarian Options?
Limited. Sides like creamed spinach and salads are available. No main vegetarian dishes.
Do I Need A Reservation?
Yes, especially for dinner. Reservations are essential, often booked weeks in advance.
Final Thoughts On Peter Luger Menu Prices
Peter Luger’s menu prices are high, but the quality is undeniable. The steaks are among the best in the country. The experience is classic New York.
If you’re planning a visit, budget carefully. Share dishes to save money. Bring cash if you’re going to Brooklyn. And don’t forget to tip well—the service is excellent.
One last thing: the prices listed here are subject to change. Always check the official menu before you go. But this guide gives you a solid baseline for what to expect.
So, now you know the Peter Luger Menu Prices. Go ahead and plan your meal. You won’t regret it.