Sugarfire menu with prices highlights their smoked meats and creative sides, helping you choose between a pulled pork sandwich or a loaded baked potato. You want real BBQ without guessing costs. This guide breaks down every item and its price so you can order with confidence.
Sugarfire Smoke House is known for bold flavors and generous portions. Their menu changes slightly by location, but the core items stay consistent. We’ll cover meats, sandwiches, platters, sides, desserts, and drinks. You’ll know exactly what to expect before you walk in.
Sugarfire Menu With Prices
Below is a full breakdown of the Sugarfire menu with prices. These are average prices from multiple locations. Actual costs may vary by a dollar or two depending on your city. Always check your local store for the most current numbers.
Smoked Meats By The Pound
You can order most meats by the pound for takeout or catering. This is great for feeding a crowd or just stocking your fridge.
- Brisket – $22 per pound
- Pulled Pork – $18 per pound
- Turkey Breast – $19 per pound
- St. Louis Ribs – $24 per full slab
- Smoked Sausage – $16 per pound
- Hot Link – $16 per pound
- Chicken Half – $12 each
Prices include your choice of one sauce per pound. Extra sauces cost $1 each. The brisket is their most popular item, so order early on weekends.
Sandwiches And Po’ Boys
Sandwiches come on a toasted bun with pickles, onions, and your choice of sauce. You can add cheese for $1 extra.
- Pulled Pork Sandwich – $11
- Brisket Sandwich – $14
- Turkey Sandwich – $12
- Smoked Sausage Po’ Boy – $11
- Hot Link Po’ Boy – $11
- Fried Chicken Sandwich – $12
- Smoked Chicken Sandwich – $11
Each sandwich comes with one side. Upgrade to a large side for $2 more. The brisket sandwich is the most filling option.
Platters And Combos
Platters give you more meat and two sides. They are perfect if you want a full meal.
- Two Meat Platter – $18
- Three Meat Platter – $23
- Rib Platter (half slab) – $20
- Chicken Platter (half bird) – $15
Choose any two sides for platters. Extra sides are $4 each. The three meat platter is the best value for hungry eaters.
Burgers And Specialty Sandwiches
These are not your average burgers. They use smoked meat patties or unique toppings.
- The Sugarfire Burger – $14
- Smash Burger – $13
- Mac & Cheese Burger – $15
- Fried Chicken & Waffle Sandwich – $13
- Loaded Baked Potato (with brisket or pulled pork) – $14
The loaded baked potato is a meal in itself. It comes with cheese, sour cream, butter, and your choice of meat. Add extra toppings like jalapeños for $1.
Sides And Salads
Sides are available in regular ($4) or large ($6) sizes. You can also order a side sampler for $10.
- Mac & Cheese
- Baked Beans
- Coleslaw
- Potato Salad
- Green Beans
- Cornbread (one piece)
- Fries (regular or sweet potato)
- Loaded Fries (with cheese and bacon) – $8
Salads include a house salad ($9) and a smoked chicken salad ($12). Dressings are ranch, blue cheese, or vinaigrette.
Kids Menu
Kids meals come with one side and a drink. They are designed for children under 12.
- Kid’s Pulled Pork – $8
- Kid’s Chicken Tenders – $8
- Kid’s Hot Dog – $7
- Kid’s Grilled Cheese – $7
Drink options include milk, juice, or soda. No substitutions on sides for kids meals.
Desserts
Save room for something sweet. Desserts are made in-house daily.
- Banana Pudding – $5
- Chocolate Chip Cookie – $3
- Brownie – $4
- Peach Cobbler – $6
- Ice Cream (vanilla or chocolate) – $4
The banana pudding is a fan favorite. It sells out fast on weekends.
Drinks
Beverages include soft drinks, tea, lemonade, and bottled water.
- Soft Drinks (Coke, Sprite, Dr Pepper) – $3
- Sweet Tea – $3
- Unsweet Tea – $3
- Lemonade – $3
- Bottled Water – $2
- Milk – $3
- Juice Box – $2
Alcoholic drinks vary by location. Some stores offer beer and wine. Ask your server for current options.
Catering And Family Packs
Feeding a group? Sugarfire offers family packs and catering trays. Order 24 hours in advance for best availability.
- Family Pack (feeds 4-6) – $55
- Large Family Pack (feeds 8-10) – $95
- Party Platter (feeds 12-15) – $150
Family packs include two meats, two large sides, and bread. You can add extra sides for $15 each. Catering trays of meat cost $50 per tray.
Daily Specials
Each day has a unique special that changes weekly. Check their social media or call ahead.
- Monday – Burnt Ends Sandwich ($12)
- Tuesday – Taco Tuesday (2 tacos for $10)
- Wednesday – Wing Wednesday (10 wings for $12)
- Thursday – Rib Night (half slab with two sides for $18)
- Friday – Fish Fry (fried catfish with two sides for $16)
- Saturday – BBQ Breakfast (brisket and eggs for $14)
- Sunday – Family Day (10% off family packs)
Specials are limited. Arrive early to avoid disappointment.
Sauces And Seasonings
You can buy Sugarfire sauces and rubs to take home.
- Original BBQ Sauce – $8 per bottle
- Spicy BBQ Sauce – $8 per bottle
- Sweet & Tangy Sauce – $8 per bottle
- Dry Rub (original or spicy) – $6 per jar
Sauces are also available in gallon jugs for catering. Ask your server for bulk pricing.
How To Order
You have several ways to get your Sugarfire fix.
- Walk in and order at the counter.
- Call ahead for pickup.
- Order online through their website.
- Use third-party delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats.
Online orders often have a small service fee. Pickup is usually faster and cheaper.
Tips For Saving Money
BBQ can add up quickly. Use these tips to keep your bill reasonable.
- Visit on a special day like Taco Tuesday or Wing Wednesday.
- Share a platter between two people.
- Skip the drinks and bring your own water.
- Order family packs if you are with a group.
- Check for coupons on their website or social media.
Kids meals are also a good deal if your child eats less.
What To Expect At Each Location
Sugarfire has locations in Missouri, Illinois, and Texas. Menus and prices can vary slightly.
- St. Louis, MO – Full menu, plus local craft beers.
- Columbia, MO – Smaller menu, but same quality.
- O’Fallon, IL – Drive-thru available.
- Dallas, TX – Larger portions and Texas-style sides.
Call ahead to confirm hours and availability. Some locations close early on Sundays.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Sugarfire have a vegetarian menu?
They offer a few vegetarian sides like coleslaw, baked beans, and mac & cheese. But there are no meatless main dishes. The loaded baked potato can be ordered without meat.
Are prices the same at all Sugarfire locations?
No, prices vary by location. Urban stores tend to be slightly higher. The differences are usually $1 to $2 per item.
Can I order Sugarfire for delivery?
Yes, through third-party apps. Delivery fees and minimum orders apply. Pickup is often cheaper.
What is the most popular item on the Sugarfire menu?
The brisket is their signature item. It sells out regularly, especially on weekends. The banana pudding is also very popular.
Does Sugarfire offer gluten-free options?
Most meats are gluten-free. Sides like coleslaw and green beans are also safe. Avoid buns and cornbread if you need gluten-free.
Final Thoughts
Knowing the Sugarfire menu with prices helps you plan your meal and budget. Whether you want a quick sandwich or a full platter, there is something for every appetite. The smoked meats are the star, but the sides and desserts hold their own. Visit on a special day for the best deals. And always check your local menu for any price changes. Now you are ready to order like a pro.