Potbelly menu prices offer a range of toasted sandwiches, salads, and shakes for any appetite. Whether you are stopping by for a quick lunch or a filling dinner, knowing what you will pay helps you plan your meal. This guide breaks down every item, combo, and deal so you can order with confidence.
Potbelly Sandwich Works is known for its warm, toasted subs and cozy shop atmosphere. But the menu can feel overwhelming if you are not sure what fits your budget. We cover the full Potbelly menu prices, from classic sandwiches to catering trays, so you never overpay.
Potbelly Menu Prices Overview
The core of Potbelly’s menu is their toasted sandwiches. You pick your bread, protein, and toppings. Prices vary by location, but the ranges below are typical across the US.
- Original Sandwiches (small): $6.50 – $7.50
- Original Sandwiches (big): $8.50 – $9.50
- Skinny Sandwiches (low-cal): $6.00 – $7.00
- Flatbread Sandwiches: $7.50 – $8.50
- Salads: $7.00 – $9.00
- Shakes and Malts: $4.50 – $5.50
- Cookies and Baked Goods: $1.50 – $2.50
- Kids Meals: $5.00 – $6.00
These prices are before tax and any local surcharges. Some cities have higher costs due to minimum wage laws. Always check the menu board at your specific Potbelly for exact numbers.
Sandwich Categories And Their Price Ranges
Potbelly groups their sandwiches into three main categories. Each has a different price point and calorie count.
Original Sandwiches are the classic toasted subs. They come on white, wheat, or rye bread. You choose from meats like roast beef, turkey, ham, or meatball. The small size is one scoop of meat. The big size is two scoops.
Skinny Sandwiches use low-calorie bread and less cheese. They are designed for dieters. The portions are smaller, but the flavor is still good.
Flatbread Sandwiches are served on a flat, crispy bread. They are lighter than the original but still filling. Popular options include the Chicken Salad and the Mediterranean.
Original Sandwich Price Breakdown
Here is a list of common original sandwiches and their typical prices.
- Roast Beef (small): $7.00
- Roast Beef (big): $9.00
- Turkey Breast (small): $6.75
- Turkey Breast (big): $8.75
- Italian (small): $7.25
- Italian (big): $9.25
- Meatball (small): $7.50
- Meatball (big): $9.50
- Chicken Salad (small): $6.50
- Chicken Salad (big): $8.50
Prices can vary by $0.50 to $1.00 depending on your region. For example, a big Italian in New York City might cost $10.00, while the same sandwich in Ohio might be $8.75.
Salad Prices And Options
If you want something lighter, Potbelly salads are a solid choice. They are made fresh and come with protein options.
- Garden Salad: $7.00
- Caesar Salad: $7.50
- Grilled Chicken Salad: $8.50
- Turkey Salad: $8.00
- Mediterranean Salad: $8.50
You can add extra protein for $1.50 to $2.00. Dressings are included in the price. The salads are large enough for a meal, but you can also get a half salad for $4.50.
Potbelly Menu Prices For Combos And Meals
Combos are where you save money. Instead of buying a sandwich, chips, and a drink separately, you get a discount.
Pick Your Combo is the standard deal. You choose a sandwich, a side, and a drink. The side can be chips, a cookie, or an apple. The drink is a fountain soda or bottled water.
- Small Sandwich Combo: $8.50 – $9.50
- Big Sandwich Combo: $10.50 – $11.50
- Skinny Sandwich Combo: $8.00 – $9.00
- Flatbread Combo: $9.50 – $10.50
If you buy a sandwich alone, you pay full price. Adding a combo upgrade costs about $2.50 to $3.00 extra. That is a good deal if you want a drink and a snack.
Kids Meals And Pricing
Potbelly offers a kids menu for children under 12. Each meal comes with a smaller sandwich, a side, and a drink.
- Kids Turkey Sandwich: $5.00
- Kids Ham Sandwich: $5.00
- Kids Grilled Cheese: $5.50
- Kids PB&J: $5.00
The side options are chips, apple slices, or a cookie. The drink is a small soda or milk. These meals are affordable and portioned for young appetites.
Shakes And Malts Price List
Potbelly shakes are thick and creamy. They come in several flavors. Prices are consistent across most locations.
- Chocolate Shake: $4.99
- Vanilla Shake: $4.99
- Strawberry Shake: $4.99
- Oreo Shake: $5.49
- Malt (any flavor): $5.49
You can add a shot of espresso for $0.75. The shakes are large and can be shared. They are also available as a float with soda for an extra $0.50.
Potbelly Menu Prices For Catering
If you are ordering for a group, Potbelly catering is a good option. They offer platters and boxes that feed multiple people.
Sandwich Platters come in two sizes. The small platter serves 5-6 people. The large platter serves 10-12 people.
- Small Sandwich Platter: $45.00 – $55.00
- Large Sandwich Platter: $80.00 – $100.00
You choose the meats and cheeses. The platter includes bread, toppings, and condiments on the side. This is great for office lunches or parties.
Salad Platters are also available. They come in the same sizes.
- Small Salad Platter: $35.00 – $45.00
- Large Salad Platter: $65.00 – $80.00
You get a mix of greens, vegetables, and dressing. Protein can be added for an extra charge.
Cookie Trays are a popular add-on. A tray of 24 cookies costs $25.00. A tray of 48 cookies costs $45.00.
Catering orders need to be placed 24 hours in advance. Prices do not include delivery fees. Some locations offer free delivery for orders over $100.
Beverage Prices At Potbelly
Drinks are sold separately or as part of a combo. Here are the standard prices.
- Fountain Soda (small): $1.99
- Fountain Soda (medium): $2.29
- Fountain Soda (large): $2.59
- Bottled Water: $1.79
- Iced Tea: $2.29
- Lemonade: $2.49
- Milk (small): $1.50
You can get free refills on fountain drinks if you dine in. Bottled drinks are not refillable.
How To Save Money On Potbelly Menu Prices
Everyone likes a deal. Here are practical ways to lower your bill at Potbelly.
- Use the app. The Potbelly app often has exclusive coupons. You can get a free cookie or a dollar off a sandwich.
- Sign up for rewards. The Potbelly Perks program gives you points for every purchase. After 10 visits, you get a free sandwich.
- Order a small sandwich. The small size is half the price of the big size. It is still filling for most people.
- Skip the combo. If you already have a drink at home, just buy the sandwich. You save $2.50 to $3.00.
- Check for student discounts. Some locations offer 10% off with a student ID. Ask at the counter.
- Buy a gift card. Sometimes gift cards come with a bonus. For example, buy a $50 card and get a $10 bonus.
These tips can save you $2 to $5 per visit. Over a month, that adds up to real savings.
Potbelly Menu Prices Vs Competitors
How does Potbelly compare to other sandwich chains? Here is a quick comparison.
- Subway: A footlong sub costs $6.00 to $8.00. Potbelly is slightly more expensive but uses higher quality ingredients.
- Jersey Mike’s: A regular sub costs $7.00 to $9.00. Similar to Potbelly, but Jersey Mike’s does not toast their bread.
- Jimmy John’s: A regular sub costs $6.00 to $8.00. Jimmy John’s is cheaper but has fewer options.
- Firehouse Subs: A medium sub costs $8.00 to $10.00. Firehouse is comparable in price and quality.
Potbelly sits in the mid-range for sandwich chains. You pay a bit more than Subway, but you get a toasted sandwich and a warmer atmosphere.
Potbelly Menu Prices By Location
Prices are not the same everywhere. Here are some examples of how location affects cost.
New York City, NY: A big Italian sandwich costs $10.25. A small combo is $10.00.
Chicago, IL: A big Italian sandwich costs $9.00. A small combo is $9.00.
Los Angeles, CA: A big Italian sandwich costs $9.75. A small combo is $9.50.
Dallas, TX: A big Italian sandwich costs $8.50. A small combo is $8.50.
As you can see, cities with higher costs of living have higher Potbelly menu prices. If you travel, expect to pay more in big cities and less in smaller towns.
Seasonal And Limited-Time Offers
Potbelly sometimes introduces special sandwiches or shakes for a limited time. These items often have unique prices.
For example, during fall, they might offer a Turkey Cranberry sandwich for $8.00. In summer, a Strawberry Lemonade shake might cost $5.50. These items are not always available, so check the menu board.
Limited-time offers are usually priced similarly to regular menu items. They are a good way to try something new without breaking your budget.
Frequently Asked Questions About Potbelly Menu Prices
Are Potbelly Menu Prices The Same At Every Location?
No, prices vary by location. Franchise-owned stores may have different prices than company-owned stores. Always check the local menu.
Does Potbelly Have A Dollar Menu?
No, Potbelly does not have a dollar menu. The cheapest item is a cookie at $1.50. The cheapest sandwich is the Skinny Turkey at $6.00.
Can I Get A Discount For Ordering Online?
Sometimes. The Potbelly app occasionally offers online-only deals. You can also use promo codes found on coupon websites.
How Much Is A Potbelly Catering Platter For 20 People?
A large sandwich platter serves 10-12 people. For 20 people, you would need two large platters, costing about $160 to $200.
Are Potbelly Prices Higher During Peak Hours?
No, Potbelly does not use surge pricing. The menu prices are the same all day. However, some locations may charge more for delivery during busy times.
Final Thoughts On Potbelly Menu Prices
Potbelly menu prices are reasonable for the quality you get. A small sandwich combo for under $10 is a good deal in most cities. The catering options are affordable for groups, and the shakes are a nice treat.
Remember to check for coupons and rewards before you order. A little planning can save you a few dollars each time. Whether you want a classic Italian or a fresh salad, Potbelly has something for your taste and budget.
If you are watching your spending, stick to small sandwiches and skip the combo. If you are feeding a crowd, the platters are cost-effective. And if you have a sweet tooth, the Oreo shake is worth the extra dollar.
Potbelly menu prices are clear and upfront. There are no hidden fees or surprise charges. You walk in, order what you want, and pay a fair price. That is the kind of dining experience everyone appreciates.
Next time you are near a Potbelly, use this guide to make your choice. You will know exactly what to expect and how much to spend. Happy eating.