Marie Callender’s Pie Menu With Prices

Marie Callender’s pie menu with prices offers a seasonal selection of fruit and cream options that change throughout the year. You can find everything from classic apple to rich chocolate silk, all at reasonable prices. Whether you are visiting a restaurant or picking up a whole pie to go, this guide breaks down the full menu and what each item costs.

Pies are the star here, but the menu also includes slices, mini pies, and special holiday offerings. Prices vary by location and season, so expect slight differences depending on where you live. Below, you will find a complete breakdown of the current menu, pricing details, and tips for getting the best value.

This section covers the full range of pies available at Marie Callender’s. The menu is divided into fruit pies, cream pies, and specialty options. Each category has its own price point, and slices are available for most flavors.

Fruit Pies

Fruit pies are baked fresh daily with seasonal ingredients. The crust is flaky and buttery, and the fillings are made from real fruit. Here are the current fruit pie options:

Apple Pie – $12.99 for a whole pie, $4.49 per slice
Cherry Pie – $13.49 whole, $4.79 slice
Peach Pie – $13.99 whole, $4.99 slice (seasonal)
Blueberry Pie – $13.49 whole, $4.79 slice
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – $14.49 whole, $5.29 slice (limited availability)

Fruit pies are available year-round, but peach and strawberry rhubarb are seasonal. You may not find them in winter months. Prices include a standard 9-inch pie that serves 6 to 8 people.

Cream Pies

Cream pies are rich and smooth, made with custard or pudding bases. They are topped with whipped cream and sometimes chocolate shavings. Here are the cream pie options:

Chocolate Silk Pie – $14.99 whole, $5.49 slice
Banana Cream Pie – $14.49 whole, $5.29 slice
Coconut Cream Pie – $14.99 whole, $5.49 slice
Lemon Meringue Pie – $13.99 whole, $4.99 slice
Key Lime Pie – $15.49 whole, $5.79 slice

Cream pies are a bit more expensive due to the ingredients and preparation time. The chocolate silk pie is a fan favorite, with a dense, fudge-like filling. Key lime pie is tart and refreshing, perfect for summer.

Specialty Pies

Specialty pies include unique flavors and seasonal offerings. These change frequently, so check with your local restaurant for current availability.

Pumpkin Pie – $13.99 whole, $4.99 slice (fall only)
Pecan Pie – $15.99 whole, $5.99 slice
Sweet Potato Pie – $14.49 whole, $5.29 slice (seasonal)
French Apple Pie – $14.99 whole, $5.49 slice
Dutch Apple Pie – $15.49 whole, $5.79 slice

Specialty pies often have a crumb topping or extra layers. The French apple pie has a streusel topping, while the Dutch apple pie has a lattice crust. Pecan pie is a holiday staple, but it is available year-round at some locations.

Mini Pies And Slices

If you do not want a whole pie, you can buy mini pies or individual slices. Mini pies are about 4 inches in diameter and perfect for one person.

Mini Fruit Pie – $3.99 each
Mini Cream Pie – $4.49 each
Slice of Fruit Pie – $4.49 to $5.29
Slice of Cream Pie – $4.99 to $5.79
Slice of Specialty Pie – $4.99 to $5.99

Mini pies are great for lunch or a quick dessert. Slices are served with a dollop of whipped cream unless you ask for it without. Prices for slices vary by flavor, with cream and specialty pies costing more.

Holiday And Seasonal Offerings

Marie Callender’s releases special pies for holidays like Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter. These are often larger or have unique decorations.

Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie – $16.99 (9-inch)
Holiday Pecan Pie – $17.99 (9-inch)
Easter Lemon Meringue – $15.49 (9-inch)
Christmas Chocolate Silk – $16.99 (9-inch)

Holiday pies are typically available for pre-order. You can pick them up the day before or the day of the holiday. Prices are higher than regular pies due to the seasonal demand and larger size.

How To Order From The Marie Callender’s Pie Menu

Ordering is simple. You can visit a restaurant, call ahead, or order online. Here are the steps to get your pie:

Check the menu online for your local restaurant. Prices may vary by location.
Choose your pie flavor and size (whole, mini, or slice).
Decide if you want it for dine-in or takeout.
Call the restaurant or use their online ordering system.
Pick up your pie at the scheduled time, or have it delivered if available.

Some locations offer delivery through third-party services like DoorDash or Uber Eats. Expect higher prices on those platforms due to service fees. For the best deal, order directly from the restaurant.

Tips For Saving Money

Pies can add up, but there are ways to save. Here are some practical tips:

Buy whole pies instead of slices. A whole pie costs less per serving.
Look for coupons on the Marie Callender’s website or in local ads.
Join the rewards program if available. Some locations offer discounts for members.
Order during off-peak times. Holiday pies are cheaper before the rush.
Share a pie with friends or family to split the cost.

These tips can help you enjoy your favorite pie without overspending. Always check for promotions before ordering.

Nutritional Information And Allergens

Marie Callender’s pies contain common allergens like wheat, dairy, eggs, and nuts. Always ask about ingredients if you have allergies. Here is a general overview:

Fruit pies contain wheat flour, butter, and sugar. Some may have nuts in the crust.
Cream pies contain dairy, eggs, and sometimes soy lecithin.
Specialty pies like pecan contain tree nuts.
Gluten-free options are not currently available on the standard menu.

For detailed nutritional information, visit the Marie Callender’s website or ask your server. Each slice of fruit pie has around 350 to 450 calories, while cream pies have 400 to 500 calories. Portion control is key if you are watching your intake.

Storage And Reheating Tips

Leftover pies should be stored properly to maintain freshness. Here is how to handle them:

Fruit pies: Store at room temperature for up to 2 days, covered with foil.
Cream pies: Refrigerate immediately and eat within 3 days.
To reheat fruit pies: Warm in a 350°F oven for 10 minutes. Do not microwave, as the crust gets soggy.
To reheat cream pies: Serve cold or at room temperature. Do not heat.

Freezing is an option for fruit pies. Wrap tightly in plastic wrap and foil, then freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the refrigerator overnight before serving.

Comparing Marie Callender’s Pie Menu With Competitors

Marie Callender’s pies are priced competitively compared to other chains. Here is a quick comparison:

Marie Callender’s: $12.99 to $15.99 for a whole pie
Bakers Square: $13.99 to $16.99 for a whole pie
Denny’s: $4.99 to $6.99 per slice
Costco: $9.99 for a whole pie (larger size)

Marie Callender’s offers a wider variety of flavors than most competitors. Their cream pies are especially popular. Costco pies are cheaper but have fewer flavor options and are not made fresh daily.

Customer Favorites And Reviews

Regular customers have strong opinions about their favorite pies. Here are the top-rated flavors based on online reviews:

Chocolate Silk Pie – Rich, smooth, and decadent. Many say it is the best on the menu.
Apple Pie – Classic and reliable. The crust is praised for being flaky.
Banana Cream Pie – Fresh bananas and creamy custard. A close second to chocolate.
Pecan Pie – Sweet and nutty, with a buttery crust. Holiday favorite.

Some customers complain about inconsistent quality between locations. A pie at one restaurant might be perfect, while another is dry or undercooked. Always check the pie before leaving the store if you are buying takeout.

Frequently Asked Questions About Marie Callender’s Pie Menu With Prices

Here are common questions people ask about the menu and pricing:

What is the most popular pie at Marie Callender’s?

The chocolate silk pie is the most popular. It has a rich, fudge-like filling and a chocolate crust. Many customers order it year-round.

Are there any gluten-free pie options?

Currently, Marie Callender’s does not offer gluten-free pies on the standard menu. Some locations may have a gluten-free crust option, but it is not guaranteed. Call ahead to ask.

Can I order a pie online for pickup?

Yes, most locations allow online ordering for pickup. You can use the Marie Callender’s website or app. Some locations also offer delivery through third-party services.

Do prices vary by location?

Yes, prices can vary by state and even by restaurant. Urban locations tend to be slightly more expensive. Always check the menu for your specific store.

How many slices are in a whole pie?

A standard 9-inch pie serves 6 to 8 slices, depending on how thick you cut them. For larger gatherings, consider ordering two pies.

Final Thoughts On Marie Callender’s Pie Menu With Prices

Marie Callender’s pie menu with prices offers something for everyone, from fruit lovers to cream pie fans. The prices are reasonable for the quality, and the variety is hard to beat. Whether you are celebrating a holiday or just want a sweet treat, you can find a pie that fits your budget.

Remember to check for seasonal offerings and local promotions. Some flavors are only available for a short time, so grab them while you can. If you are unsure which pie to try, start with the chocolate silk or the apple pie. Both are customer favorites for good reason.

For the best experience, order a whole pie and share it with friends. Slices are convenient, but whole pies give you more for your money. And if you have leftovers, store them properly to enjoy later.

Marie Callender’s has been making pies for decades, and the quality shows. The crust is consistently flaky, the fillings are flavorful, and the prices are fair. Next time you are in the mood for dessert, check out the menu and pick your favorite.

One thing to note: prices can change without notice. The figures in this article are based on current averages, but your local restaurant may have different pricing. Always confirm before ordering to avoid surprises.

In summary, the Marie Callender’s pie menu with prices is straightforward and affordable. You get fresh, high-quality pies at a reasonable cost. Whether you choose fruit, cream, or specialty, you will not be disappointed. Enjoy your slice!