Summer evenings taste better when you know exactly how much a concrete mixer will cost before you order. The Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices is your go-to guide for planning that perfect treat without any surprise at the register.
Andy’s is famous for its thick, creamy frozen custard made fresh every day. But the menu can feel a bit overwhelming with all the options. This article breaks down every item, size, and price so you can order with confidence.
Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices
Let’s get straight to the numbers. Below is the full breakdown of Andy’s menu categories and their current prices. Keep in mind that prices can vary slightly by location, but these are the standard ranges as of mid-2025.
Concrete Mixers
This is Andy’s signature item. A concrete mixer is thick custard blended with your choice of mix-ins. It’s served upside down to prove how dense it is.
- Small Concrete Mixer: $4.29
- Medium Concrete Mixer: $5.19
- Large Concrete Mixer: $6.09
You can add extra mix-ins for $0.75 each. Popular choices include cookie dough, brownie bites, and fresh strawberries.
Sundaes
Classic hot fudge sundaes and specialty options are available. They come with whipped cream and a cherry on top.
- Regular Sundae: $4.49
- Large Sundae: $5.39
- Caramel Pecan Sundae: $5.29
- Brownie Sundae: $5.79
Shakes And Malts
Andy’s shakes are thick and hand-spun. Malts add that extra malted milk flavor.
- Small Shake: $4.49
- Medium Shake: $5.39
- Large Shake: $6.29
- Malt (any size): add $0.50
Frozen Custard Cones
Simple and classic. Choose from a cake cone or a waffle cone.
- Kid’s Cone: $2.29
- Small Cone: $3.29
- Medium Cone: $4.19
- Large Cone: $5.09
- Waffle Cone upgrade: $0.75
Custard Cups
Just the custard, no cone. Perfect for those who want to keep it simple.
- Small Cup: $3.29
- Medium Cup: $4.19
- Large Cup: $5.09
Floats
Root beer float or any soda float. Andy’s uses their vanilla custard for this.
- Regular Float: $4.79
- Large Float: $5.69
Specialty Items
These rotate seasonally but here are some staples.
- Banana Split: $6.49
- Brownie Concrete Mixer: $6.29
- Cookie Monster Concrete: $6.49
How To Order Like A Pro
Ordering at Andy’s is easy once you know the lingo. Here is a step-by-step guide.
Step 1: Pick Your Base
Decide if you want a cone, cup, or concrete mixer. Cones are great for walking around. Concrete mixers are for when you want a meal in a cup.
Step 2: Choose Your Size
Andy’s has four sizes: Kid’s, Small, Medium, and Large. Kid’s is perfect for a small treat. Large is almost a full meal.
Step 3: Select Your Flavor
Andy’s has three standard flavors every day: Vanilla, Chocolate, and a Flavor of the Day. The flavor of the day rotates and is often seasonal.
Step 4: Add Mix-Ins
For concrete mixers, you can pick up to three mix-ins at no extra cost. After that, each additional mix-in is $0.75.
Popular mix-ins include:
- Cookie dough chunks
- Brownie pieces
- Fresh strawberries
- Hot fudge
- Caramel
- Reese’s cups
- M&M’s
- Oreo pieces
Step 5: Pay And Enjoy
Hand over your cash or card. They will hand you your custard upside down if you ordered a concrete. It’s a fun tradition.
Seasonal And Limited Time Offers
Andy’s rotates special items throughout the year. These are worth watching for.
Summer Specials
During summer, you might find a Peach Concrete Mixer or a Lemon Berry Sundae. Prices for these are usually around $5.49 to $6.79.
Holiday Flavors
Around Christmas, expect Peppermint Concrete Mixers and Eggnog shakes. These are typically $5.29 to $6.49.
Flavor Of The Day Calendar
Andy’s publishes a monthly flavor calendar. You can check their website or app to see what is coming. Some popular flavors include:
- Banana Pudding
- Red Velvet
- Key Lime Pie
- Butter Pecan
- Mint Chocolate Chip
Nutritional Information And Allergens
Knowing what is in your custard helps you make informed choices. Here is a quick overview.
Calories And Macros
A small vanilla concrete mixer with no mix-ins has about 350 calories. Add cookie dough and hot fudge, and it jumps to around 600 calories.
- Small Concrete (vanilla): 350 cal
- Medium Concrete (vanilla): 480 cal
- Large Concrete (vanilla): 620 cal
- Small Shake: 420 cal
- Medium Shake: 580 cal
Allergen Notes
Andy’s custard contains milk, eggs, and wheat (in cones). Mix-ins may contain peanuts, tree nuts, soy, and gluten. If you have allergies, ask the staff for the full allergen guide.
Dietary Options
Andy’s does not offer vegan or dairy-free custard. They do have a few gluten-free options if you skip the cone and choose a cup. Some locations offer a sugar-free vanilla custard, but it is not always available.
Comparing Andy’s To Other Custard Shops
How does Andy’s stack up against competitors? Here is a quick comparison.
Andy’s Vs. Culver’s
Culver’s has a similar menu but their concrete mixers are slightly smaller. Andy’s custard is denser and richer. Prices are comparable, with Andy’s being about $0.50 more per item on average.
Andy’s Vs. Freddy’s
Freddy’s has a thinner custard. Andy’s is thicker and more traditional. Freddy’s prices are a bit lower, but Andy’s portions are bigger.
Andy’s Vs. Local Shops
Local custard shops vary widely. Andy’s is consistent across locations. You know what you are getting every time.
Tips For Saving Money At Andy’s
Frozen custard is a treat, but it can add up. Here are some ways to keep costs down.
Use The App
Andy’s has a mobile app with exclusive deals. You can earn points for free custard. Sign up and get a free small concrete on your first order.
Check For Coupons
Some locations have coupons in local mailers or on social media. Follow your local Andy’s on Facebook for flash deals.
Order A Kid’s Size
Kid’s cones and cups are under $2.50. They are perfect for a small craving without the big price.
Skip The Extras
Extra mix-ins and waffle cones add cost. Stick with a simple concrete or a regular cone to save.
Go During Happy Hour
Some Andy’s locations have happy hour discounts on certain days. Ask your local store if they offer any time-based deals.
What To Expect When You Visit
First time at Andy’s? Here is what the experience is like.
The Atmosphere
Andy’s has a retro, 1950s diner feel. Red and white checkered floors, chrome stools, and classic music. It is clean and family-friendly.
The Service
Staff are usually fast and friendly. They will explain the menu if you ask. Expect a line during peak hours, but it moves quickly.
The Wait Time
Concrete mixers take a bit longer because they are hand-mixed. Expect 3 to 5 minutes for a concrete. Cones and cups are faster.
Drive-Through Vs. Walk-In
Most Andy’s have a drive-through. The line can be long on summer nights. Walk-in is often faster if you are in a hurry.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to common questions about Andy’s Frozen Custard menu and prices.
What is the difference between a concrete and a shake?
A concrete is thick custard blended with mix-ins. It is served with a spoon. A shake is thinner and drinkable through a straw. Concretes have more custard and less milk.
Does Andy’s have sugar-free options?
Some locations offer a sugar-free vanilla custard. It is not always available. Ask at your local store. They do not have sugar-free mix-ins.
Can I order online or through the app?
Yes, you can order ahead through the Andy’s app. You can also order for pickup at some locations. Check the app for availability.
Are there any gluten-free items on the menu?
The custard itself is gluten-free. Cones contain gluten. If you order a cup or a concrete in a cup, it is gluten-free. Be careful with mix-ins that may contain gluten.
How much is a large concrete mixer at Andy’s?
A large concrete mixer is $6.09. Adding extra mix-ins costs $0.75 each. A large with two extra mix-ins would be $7.59.
Final Thoughts On The Andy’s Menu
Andy’s Frozen Custard offers a wide range of options at reasonable prices. The menu is simple once you understand the categories. Concretes are the star, but sundaes and shakes are also excellent.
Remember that prices can vary by location. The figures in this article are averages. Always check the menu board at your local Andy’s for exact prices.
Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, knowing the Andy’s Frozen Custard Menu With Prices helps you make a smart choice. Now you can walk in, order confidently, and enjoy every spoonful.
Next time you see that red and white sign, you will know exactly what to get and how much it will cost. That is the power of being prepared.
So go ahead, treat yourself. You deserve a concrete mixer on a hot summer night. And now you know it won’t break the bank.