Long John Silver’s secret menu items like the “Fisherman’s Platter” come with prices that vary by region. If you’re looking for Long John Silver’s secret menu with prices, you’ve come to the right place. This guide breaks down every off-menu item, what they cost, and how to order them without confusing the cashier.
Let’s be real: fast food secret menus are hit or miss. Some chains have official ones, others are just customer hacks. Long John Silver’s falls somewhere in the middle. They don’t advertise these items, but many locations will make them if you ask nicely. The key is knowing what to ask for and what to expect to pay.
Below, I’ll walk you through the most popular secret menu items, their approximate prices, and tips for getting them. I’ve also included a few regional variations because prices can swing by a dollar or two depending on where you live.
What Is The Long John Silver’s Secret Menu?
The Long John Silver’s secret menu isn’t an official document. It’s a collection of custom orders, combo swaps, and regional items that regulars have figured out over the years. Some items are just clever combinations of existing ingredients. Others are limited-time offers that became fan favorites.
Most employees will make these items if you’re polite and specific. But don’t expect every location to have the same prices. That’s why I’ve included price ranges throughout this article.
How To Order From The Secret Menu
Ordering is simple. Just say the name of the item and describe it if the cashier looks confused. For example: “Can I get a Fisherman’s Platter? That’s two pieces of fish, two shrimp, two hushpuppies, and fries.” Most will nod and ring it up as a custom combo.
If they say no, don’t push it. Some franchise owners have strict rules. Just try a different location next time.
Long John Silver’s Secret Menu With Prices
Here’s the full breakdown of secret menu items, organized by category. Prices are averages based on reports from multiple locations. Your actual cost may vary by a few cents or dollars.
1. The Fisherman’s Platter
This is the most requested secret item. It’s basically a sampler platter with two pieces of battered fish, two butterfly shrimp, two hushpuppies, and a side of fries. Some locations also add a small coleslaw.
Price range: $8.99 to $10.99
How to order: “I’d like a Fisherman’s Platter, please.” If they don’t know it, say: “Can I get two pieces of fish, two shrimp, two hushpuppies, and a regular fry?”
Tip: Ask for extra tartar sauce. The platter doesn’t always come with enough.
2. The Ultimate Platter
This is like the Fisherman’s Platter but bigger. You get three pieces of fish, four shrimp, three hushpuppies, and a large fry. Some locations also throw in a small drink.
Price range: $11.99 to $13.99
How to order: “Can I get the Ultimate Platter?” If they’re unsure, explain: “Three fish, four shrimp, three hushpuppies, large fries.”
Note: This item is more common in the southern US. Northern locations might charge extra.
3. The Chicken And Fish Combo
Long John Silver’s sells chicken tenders and fish, but they don’t advertise a combo that mixes both. You can order one piece of fish and two chicken tenders with fries and a drink.
Price range: $7.49 to $9.49
How to order: “I’d like one piece of fish and two chicken tenders as a combo with fries and a drink.”
Why it works: Most registers have a “custom combo” button. The cashier just needs to know what you want.
4. The Shrimp Po’ Boy
This isn’t on the menu, but you can make it by ordering a crispy fish sandwich and asking them to swap the fish for shrimp. They’ll use the same bun, lettuce, and tartar sauce.
Price range: $5.49 to $6.99
How to order: “Can I get a crispy fish sandwich but with shrimp instead of fish?”
Warning: Some locations might charge for the shrimp as a separate item. Ask about the price before they ring it up.
5. The Double Fish Sandwich
Two pieces of battered fish on one bun. Simple, filling, and cheap.
Price range: $4.99 to $6.49
How to order: “Can I get a double fish sandwich? Two pieces of fish on one bun.”
Pro tip: Add cheese for an extra $0.50. Some locations have it, some don’t.
6. The Hushpuppy Side Upgrade
Instead of fries, you can ask for hushpuppies as your side. Most locations will do this at no extra charge, but some might add $0.50 to $1.00.
Price range: Same as regular side, or +$0.50 to $1.00
How to order: “Can I get hushpuppies instead of fries with my meal?”
Note: This works best with combo meals. Don’t try it with the value menu items.
7. The Grilled Fish Platter
Long John Silver’s has grilled fish on the menu, but not as a platter. You can ask for two pieces of grilled fish with two sides (like coleslaw and corn) and hushpuppies.
Price range: $8.99 to $10.99
How to order: “Can I get two pieces of grilled fish with two sides and hushpuppies?”
Health note: This is one of the lower-calorie secret menu options. The grilled fish has about 200 calories per piece.
8. The Popcorn Shrimp Basket
Popcorn shrimp is usually only available as a side or in a combo. You can ask for a basket of just popcorn shrimp with fries and hushpuppies.
Price range: $6.99 to $8.99
How to order: “I’d like a popcorn shrimp basket with fries and hushpuppies.”
Portion size: You’ll get about 12-15 pieces of popcorn shrimp. It’s a good snack for one person.
9. The Clam Strip Combo
Clam strips are on the menu as a side, but you can order them as a combo with fries, hushpuppies, and a drink.
Price range: $7.49 to $9.49
How to order: “Can I get a clam strip combo? That’s clam strips, fries, hushpuppies, and a drink.”
Availability: Not all locations carry clam strips. Call ahead to check.
10. The Fish And Shrimp Combo
This is similar to the Fisherman’s Platter but smaller. You get one piece of fish, four shrimp, fries, and hushpuppies.
Price range: $7.99 to $9.99
How to order: “Can I get one piece of fish and four shrimp as a combo with fries and hushpuppies?”
Why it’s secret: The menu only offers fish and shrimp as separate combos. Combining them saves you about $1.50.
Regional Price Variations
Prices for secret menu items can change based on where you live. Here’s a quick breakdown by region:
- South (Texas, Florida, Georgia): Prices are usually on the lower end. The Fisherman’s Platter might cost $8.99.
- Midwest (Ohio, Indiana, Illinois): Average prices. Expect to pay $9.99 for most platters.
- West Coast (California, Oregon): Higher prices due to cost of living. The Ultimate Platter can hit $13.99.
- Northeast (New York, Pennsylvania): Similar to West Coast. Some locations charge extra for custom orders.
If you’re traveling, ask about prices before you order. It saves you from sticker shock.
Tips For Ordering Secret Menu Items
Getting your secret menu item isn’t always easy. Here are some tips to make it smoother:
- Be polite. Cashiers are more likely to help if you’re nice. Say please and thank you.
- Know what you want. Have the item name and ingredients ready. Don’t make them guess.
- Ask about prices first. Some items might cost more than you expect. Get a quote before they ring it up.
- Go during slow hours. Lunch rush is not the time to experiment. Try mid-afternoon or late evening.
- Check the app. Some secret items are actually available on the Long John Silver’s app under “customize.”
- Bring cash. Some locations don’t allow custom orders on credit cards. Cash is easier for manual adjustments.
Secret Menu Hacks For Extra Value
Beyond the official secret items, there are a few hacks to save money:
- Order a kid’s meal and add a side. Kid’s meals are cheaper and come with a drink. Add a side of shrimp for $2.00.
- Ask for extra hushpuppies. Some locations give them for free if you ask nicely. Others charge $0.50.
- Use the “2 for $5” deal. If your location has it, you can get two fish sandwiches for $5. Add a side for $1.00.
- Bring your own sauce. Long John Silver’s charges for extra sauce packets. Bring your own tartar or cocktail sauce.
What Not To Order
Not every secret menu item is worth it. Here are a few to skip:
- The “Super Platter” – Some locations offer this, but it’s just the Ultimate Platter with extra fries. Not worth the $2 upcharge.
- The “Grilled Chicken Sandwich” – They don’t have grilled chicken. You’ll just get a fried chicken patty on a bun.
- The “Fish Tacos” – They don’t have tortillas. You’d have to bring your own, which is weird.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Long John Silver’s Have An Official Secret Menu?
No, there’s no official secret menu. The items listed here are customer-created or regional specials that some locations will make on request.
Can I Get A Secret Menu Item At Any Long John Silver’s?
Not always. Franchise owners have the final say. Some locations are strict about sticking to the menu. Others are more flexible.
Are Secret Menu Items More Expensive?
Sometimes. Custom combos can cost a dollar or two more than regular combos. Always ask for the price before ordering.
What’s The Cheapest Secret Menu Item?
The Double Fish Sandwich is usually the cheapest at around $4.99. The Hushpuppy Side Upgrade is free at most locations.
Can I Order Secret Menu Items Through The App?
Some items are available if you use the “customize” option. For example, you can add extra shrimp to a combo. But most secret items need to be ordered in person.
Final Thoughts On The Secret Menu
Long John Silver’s secret menu is a fun way to mix up your usual order. The Fisherman’s Platter and Ultimate Platter are the most popular choices, and they’re usually worth the extra effort. Just remember that prices vary by location, so always ask first.
If you’re on a budget, stick with the Double Fish Sandwich or the Hushpuppy Side Upgrade. If you’re hungry, go for the Ultimate Platter. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try the Shrimp Po’ Boy.
One last thing: don’t be afraid to ask for something that’s not on this list. Long John Silver’s employees are usually happy to help if you’re polite. You might even discover a new secret menu item that no one else knows about.
So next time you’re at Long John Silver’s, skip the regular menu and try something from the secret list. Your taste buds will thank you, and your wallet won’t hate you either.