Ithaca Deli serves up hearty sandwiches and fresh salads in the heart of Ithaca, with a menu and prices that reflect local quality. When you search for Ithaca Deli Ithaca NY menu and prices, you want real numbers and real options. This guide gives you exactly that—no fluff, just the details you need to plan your next meal.
You will find everything from classic deli meats to vegetarian choices. The prices stay fair for the portion sizes. Let’s break down what you can order and what it will cost you.
Ithaca Deli Ithaca Ny Menu And Prices
This section covers the full menu lineup. You get sandwiches, salads, soups, and sides. Each item has a clear price tag so you know what to expect before you walk in.
Sandwiches And Subs
Sandwiches are the star here. They use fresh bread and generous fillings. You can choose from cold or hot options.
- Classic Turkey Club – $9.50
- Roast Beef and Cheddar – $10.25
- Italian Combo – $10.75
- Grilled Chicken Panini – $11.00
- Veggie Wrap – $8.75
- Pastrami on Rye – $11.50
- Tuna Salad Sandwich – $8.50
- BLT with Avocado – $9.25
Each sandwich comes with lettuce, tomato, and onion. You can add extra toppings like jalapeños or roasted peppers for $0.75 each.
Salads And Bowls
Salads are made to order. They use local greens when available. Portions are large enough for a full meal.
- Garden Salad – $7.50
- Caesar Salad – $8.25
- Grilled Chicken Salad – $10.00
- Greek Salad – $9.50
- Southwest Bowl – $10.75
- Chef Salad – $11.25
Dressings include ranch, balsamic vinaigrette, honey mustard, and blue cheese. You can add grilled tofu for $2.00 extra.
Soups And Chili
Soup changes daily. They always have at least two options. Chili is available year-round.
- Cup of Soup – $4.50
- Bowl of Soup – $6.25
- Chili (cup) – $5.00
- Chili (bowl) – $7.00
- Soup and Half Sandwich Combo – $9.75
Popular soups include tomato basil, chicken noodle, and lentil. Check their board for the daily special.
Sides And Snacks
These are perfect for sharing or adding to your meal. They keep it simple and tasty.
- Potato Salad – $3.50
- Coleslaw – $3.25
- Macaroni Salad – $3.50
- Pickle Spear – $1.00
- Bag of Chips – $1.50
- Fresh Fruit Cup – $4.00
Breakfast Items
They serve breakfast until 11 AM on weekdays and until noon on weekends. You can grab a quick bite before work.
- Breakfast Sandwich – $6.50
- Bagel with Cream Cheese – $3.75
- Oatmeal with Toppings – $5.00
- Yogurt Parfait – $4.50
- Egg and Cheese Wrap – $7.00
You can add bacon, sausage, or ham for $1.50 each. Coffee is $2.25 per cup with free refills.
Beverages
Drink options include soda, iced tea, and bottled water. They also have local craft sodas.
- Canned Soda – $1.75
- Bottled Water – $1.50
- Iced Tea – $2.25
- Local Craft Soda – $2.50
- Milk or Chocolate Milk – $2.00
How To Order At Ithaca Deli
Ordering is straightforward. You can walk in and order at the counter. They also take phone orders for pickup.
- Look at the menu board above the counter.
- Tell the staff your sandwich or salad choice.
- Choose your bread or wrap.
- Select any extra toppings.
- Pay at the register.
- Wait for your number to be called.
They do not take online orders yet. But you can call ahead to save time during lunch rush.
Payment Options
They accept cash, credit cards, and debit cards. There is no minimum for card payments. They do not accept checks.
What Makes The Menu Stand Out
The menu focuses on fresh ingredients. They source produce from local farms when possible. Meats come from regional suppliers.
Portion sizes are generous. A half sandwich is still filling for most people. You can order a half sandwich with soup or salad for a balanced meal.
Customization Options
You can modify almost any item. They will swap bread types or remove ingredients. Gluten-free bread is available for an extra $1.50.
Vegan options include the veggie wrap and garden salad. You can add hummus or avocado for extra protein.
Daily Specials
They run daily specials that change each week. These often feature seasonal ingredients. Prices for specials range from $8.00 to $12.00.
Ask at the counter about the special of the day. It is usually written on a chalkboard near the register.
Price Comparison With Other Ithaca Delis
Prices here are average for the area. You pay a little more than chain delis but get better quality. Portions are bigger than most competitors.
- Turkey Club: Ithaca Deli $9.50 vs. average $10.00
- Grilled Chicken Panini: Ithaca Deli $11.00 vs. average $11.50
- Garden Salad: Ithaca Deli $7.50 vs. average $8.00
You save about $0.50 to $1.00 per item compared to other local delis. The quality makes it a good value.
Tips For First-Time Visitors
If you have never been, here are some practical tips. They will help you get the best experience.
- Go before 12:15 PM to avoid the lunch line.
- Bring cash if you want to tip easily.
- Ask for extra napkins—sandwiches can be messy.
- Try the Italian combo if you want a classic deli taste.
- Check the soup board before ordering a sandwich.
The staff is friendly but busy during peak hours. Be ready with your order when you reach the counter.
Best Times To Visit
Weekdays are less crowded than weekends. Early morning is quiet for breakfast. Late afternoon is slow between 2 PM and 4 PM.
Avoid the lunch rush from 12 PM to 1:30 PM if you want quick service. Dinner time is also busy but shorter lines.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are common questions people ask about Ithaca Deli Ithaca NY menu and prices.
Does Ithaca Deli have vegetarian options?
Yes. They offer veggie wraps, garden salads, and grilled cheese. You can also customize sandwiches to remove meat.
Can I order a half sandwich?
Yes. Half sandwiches are available for most items. They cost about 60% of the full price.
Do they have gluten-free bread?
Yes. Gluten-free bread is available for an extra $1.50. They also have gluten-free wraps.
What are the hours of operation?
They are open Monday to Saturday from 7 AM to 8 PM. Sunday hours are 8 AM to 6 PM.
Is there seating inside?
Yes. They have about 20 seats inside. There are also a few tables outside during warm weather.
How The Menu Changes Seasonally
Ithaca Deli adjusts its menu based on what is fresh. In summer, you will find more local tomatoes and corn. Winter brings heartier soups and stews.
Prices stay stable through the year. You might see a slight increase for seasonal specials, but core items keep the same price.
Summer Menu Highlights
- Fresh Tomato and Mozzarella Sandwich – $9.75
- Grilled Vegetable Wrap – $8.50
- Watermelon and Feta Salad – $9.00
Winter Menu Highlights
- Hearty Beef Stew – $7.50
- Roasted Vegetable Panini – $10.00
- Butternut Squash Soup – $5.50
Comparing Ithaca Deli To Other Local Eateries
Other delis in Ithaca include Collegetown Bagels and The Nines. Ithaca Deli focuses more on classic deli fare with a local twist.
Collegetown Bagels is known for bagels and breakfast. The Nines has a wider menu but higher prices. Ithaca Deli hits a sweet spot for lunch.
If you want a quick, filling meal under $12, Ithaca Deli is a solid choice. The quality is consistent across all menu items.
What Customers Say About The Menu
Regulars praise the turkey club and the Italian combo. Many note the generous portion sizes. Some say the soup is the best in town.
Criticism is rare but includes slow service during peak hours. A few customers wish they had more vegan options. Overall, reviews are positive.
Common Compliments
- Fresh ingredients
- Large portions
- Friendly staff
- Fair prices
Common Complaints
- Long lines at lunch
- Limited vegan choices
- No online ordering
How To Save Money At Ithaca Deli
You can keep your bill low with a few strategies. Order a half sandwich with a cup of soup for under $10. Skip the extras like avocado or extra meat.
Bring your own drink to save $2.00. They do not charge for water cups if you ask nicely.
Check for combo deals. The soup and half sandwich combo is the best value at $9.75.
Final Thoughts On The Menu And Prices
Ithaca Deli offers a straightforward menu with fair prices. You get quality ingredients and generous portions. The Ithaca Deli Ithaca NY menu and prices are easy to understand and budget-friendly.
Whether you want a quick lunch or a hearty breakfast, this deli delivers. Go early to avoid crowds and enjoy your meal.
If you are visiting Ithaca for the first time, put this deli on your list. It represents the local food scene well—simple, fresh, and satisfying.
Remember to check the daily specials board. You might find a new favorite dish at a great price. Enjoy your meal at Ithaca Deli.