Casey’s Pizza Menu Prices

Casey’s pizza menu prices vary by size and toppings, making it easy to feed a crowd on a budget. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick slice or ordering a whole pie for game night, Casey’s has options that won’t break the bank. Let’s break down everything you need to know about their pizza pricing, sizes, and deals.

Casey’s General Store isn’t just a gas station—it’s a legit pizza destination. Their made-from-scratch dough, signature sauce, and fresh toppings have earned a loyal following. The menu is simple but satisfying, with three main pizza sizes and a variety of topping choices.

Pizza Size Options And Base Prices

Casey’s offers three pizza sizes: personal, medium, and large. Each size has a base price that includes cheese and sauce. Additional toppings cost extra, but the base price gives you a solid starting point.

Personal Pizza (8-inch): $5.99 base price. Perfect for one person or a light meal.
Medium Pizza (12-inch): $9.99 base price. Good for sharing between two people.
Large Pizza (14-inch): $12.99 base price. Feeds a family or group of friends.

These prices can vary slightly by location, so check with your local Casey’s for exact numbers. But in general, you’re looking at affordable pizza that competes with major chains.

Topping Prices And Combinations

Adding toppings to your Casey’s pizza is where the cost adds up. Each topping costs extra, but you can mix and match to create your perfect pie. Here’s a typical breakdown:

Single topping: $1.50 extra on personal, $2.00 on medium, $2.50 on large.
Two toppings: $2.50 extra on personal, $3.00 on medium, $3.50 on large.
Three or more toppings: $3.50 extra on personal, $4.00 on medium, $4.50 on large.

Popular toppings include pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives. Casey’s also offers specialty pizzas with pre-set topping combinations, which we’ll cover next.

Specialty Pizza Options And Pricing

Casey’s has a few signature pizzas that come with specific toppings. These are often a better deal than building your own from scratch. Here are the main specialty options:

Pepperoni Pizza: Classic choice. Personal $7.49, Medium $11.99, Large $15.49.
Sausage Pizza: Same pricing as pepperoni. Personal $7.49, Medium $11.99, Large $15.49.
Supreme Pizza: Loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Personal $9.49, Medium $14.99, Large $18.99.
Cheese Pizza: Just cheese and sauce. Personal $5.99, Medium $9.99, Large $12.99.

These prices are approximate and can vary. But you can see that specialty pizzas offer good value if you want multiple toppings without paying per item.

Deals And Combos To Save Money

Casey’s often runs promotions that make their pizza even more affordable. Look for these common deals:

Pizza and Pop Combo: Get a large pizza and a 2-liter soda for around $15.99.
Slice and Drink Deal: A single slice plus a fountain drink for $3.99.
Family Meal Deal: Large pizza, breadsticks, and a 2-liter soda for $19.99.
Rewards Program: Sign up for Casey’s Rewards to earn points on every purchase. Points can be redeemed for free pizza or discounts.

These deals change by location and season, so check the app or ask in-store. Using the rewards program is a smart way to save over time.

How To Order Casey’s Pizza

Ordering from Casey’s is straightforward. You can do it in person, online, or through their mobile app. Here’s a step-by-step guide:

Choose your size: Decide between personal, medium, or large based on how many people you’re feeding.
Pick your crust: Casey’s offers thin crust, hand-tossed, and pan crust. Thin crust is crispier, hand-tossed is chewy, and pan crust is thick and fluffy.
Select your sauce: Options include classic red, garlic butter, or BBQ. Classic red is the standard.
Add cheese: Extra cheese costs about $1.00 more. You can also ask for less cheese.
Choose toppings: Pick from the list or go with a specialty pizza. Remember the pricing tiers for multiple toppings.
Add extras: Consider breadsticks, cinnamon sticks, or a salad to round out your meal.
Place your order: Pay online or at the counter. Casey’s typically has your pizza ready in 15-20 minutes.

If you’re ordering for a large group, call ahead to ensure they have enough ingredients. Casey’s makes pizza fresh daily, but popular toppings can run out during busy times.

Comparing Casey’s Pizza To Other Chains

How does Casey’s stack up against Domino’s, Pizza Hut, or Little Caesars? Price-wise, Casey’s is competitive. Here’s a quick comparison:

Domino’s: Large cheese pizza starts at $12.99, similar to Casey’s. But Domino’s often has coupons that bring the price down.
Pizza Hut: Large cheese pizza is around $14.99, a bit higher than Casey’s. Their specialty pizzas cost more.
Little Caesars: Large pepperoni pizza is $7.99, cheaper than Casey’s. But the quality is different—Casey’s uses fresh dough and higher-quality toppings.
Papa John’s: Large cheese pizza is $13.99, comparable to Casey’s. Papa John’s has more topping options but similar pricing.

Casey’s stands out for its fresh ingredients and convenience. You can grab a pizza while filling up your gas tank, which saves time. The taste is often rated higher than fast-food chains, especially for the price.

Nutritional Information And Dietary Options

If you’re watching your diet, Casey’s pizza can fit into your plan with some adjustments. Here are the basics:

Calories per slice (large cheese): About 250-300 calories, depending on crust type.
Thin crust: Lower in calories and carbs compared to pan crust.
Gluten-free options: Casey’s does not offer gluten-free crust at most locations. Check with your local store.
Vegetarian options: Load up on veggies like mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and olives. Cheese pizza is also vegetarian.
Meat lovers: Add pepperoni, sausage, bacon, or ham for extra protein.

Casey’s provides nutritional info on their website for each pizza. You can also ask for a lighter cheese option to reduce calories.

Tips For Getting The Best Value

Want to maximize your money at Casey’s? Follow these tips:

Buy a large pizza: The price per slice is lower on large pizzas compared to personal or medium sizes.
Stick to one or two toppings: Adding many toppings drives up the cost. Choose your favorites and keep it simple.
Use the rewards app: Earn points on every purchase and redeem them for free pizza or discounts.
Look for weekly specials: Casey’s often has a pizza of the week at a discounted price. Ask in-store or check the app.
Order during off-peak hours: Some locations offer discounts for orders placed before 4 PM or after 8 PM.
Share with friends: Splitting a large pizza with two or three people is cheaper than buying individual slices.

These strategies can save you a few dollars each time you order. Over a month, that adds up to significant savings.

Customer Reviews And Popular Opinions

What do customers say about Casey’s pizza? Most reviews are positive, with a few common themes:

Fresh taste: Many people love the made-from-scratch dough and real cheese. It’s not greasy like some chains.
Good value: The price-to-quality ratio is excellent. You get a better pizza than most fast-food places for a similar cost.
Convenience: Being able to order pizza while getting gas is a big plus for travelers and busy families.
Consistency: Some locations vary in quality. It’s best to find a Casey’s that consistently makes good pizza.
Limited menu: A few customers wish Casey’s offered more specialty pizzas or unique toppings. But the simple menu works for most.

Overall, Casey’s has a strong reputation among pizza lovers. It’s not gourmet, but it’s reliable and tasty for the price.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is a large Casey’s pizza with pepperoni?

A large pepperoni pizza at Casey’s typically costs around $15.49. This includes the base price plus the pepperoni topping. Prices may vary by location.

Does Casey’s offer any pizza deals or coupons?

Yes, Casey’s often has deals like pizza and soda combos, slice and drink specials, and family meal bundles. Check the Casey’s app or website for current offers in your area.

Can I order Casey’s pizza online for delivery?

Most Casey’s locations offer online ordering through their website or app. Delivery availability depends on the store. Some locations deliver, while others are pickup-only.

What are the cheapest items on Casey’s pizza menu?

The cheapest pizza option is a personal cheese pizza at $5.99. A slice of cheese pizza is also affordable, usually around $2.49. Combo deals can bring the cost down further.

Are there any vegetarian pizza options at Casey’s?

Yes, Casey’s offers cheese pizza and veggie toppings like mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and black olives. You can build your own vegetarian pizza or order a cheese pizza.

Final Thoughts On Casey’s Pizza Menu Prices

Casey’s pizza menu prices are fair and competitive, especially considering the fresh ingredients. Whether you’re feeding yourself or a crowd, there’s a size and topping combination that fits your budget. The key is to take advantage of deals, use the rewards program, and stick to simpler topping choices to keep costs low.

Next time you’re at a Casey’s General Store, skip the gas station snacks and grab a pizza. You might be surprised at how good it tastes for the price. And with the tips in this article, you’ll know exactly how to order without overspending.

Remember to check your local Casey’s for exact pricing and promotions. Prices can vary by state and even by store. But overall, Casey’s remains a solid choice for affordable, tasty pizza that’s convenient to get.

So go ahead—try a large pepperoni or build your own supreme. Your wallet and your stomach will thank you.