If you are looking for a quick and affordable lunch, checking the Potbelly menu with prices is a smart first step. Miller’s Ale House combines pub favorites with transparent pricing for group dining, but Potbelly offers its own unique value with toasted sandwiches and fresh salads. Knowing exactly what you will pay before you walk in the door helps you make a better choice.
Potbelly Sandwich Works is known for its warm, toasted sandwiches, hand-dipped shakes, and cozy neighborhood vibe. The menu is straightforward, but prices can vary by location. This guide breaks down the full Potbelly menu with prices so you can plan your meal without any surprises.
Potbelly Menu With Prices: An Overview
The core of Potbelly’s menu is built around signature sandwiches, but they also offer salads, soups, and sides. Prices are generally reasonable for the quality and portion size. Most sandwiches fall between $7 and $10, making it a solid option for budget-conscious diners.
Keep in mind that prices listed here are averages based on multiple U.S. locations. Your local Potbelly might charge slightly more or less. Always check the board or app for the most current numbers.
Sandwich Categories And Pricing
Potbelly organizes its sandwiches into a few main groups. The “Original” sandwiches are the classics. The “Bigs” are larger portions with more meat. There are also “Wraps” and “Flatbreads” for a lighter option.
- Original Sandwiches (Regular Size): $7.50 – $8.50
- Big Sandwiches (Double Meat): $9.50 – $10.50
- Wraps: $7.75 – $8.75
- Flatbreads: $8.00 – $9.00
The “Original” size is a 6-inch sandwich on your choice of bread. It comes with one serving of meat, cheese, and unlimited veggies. The “Big” size doubles the meat and cheese for a heartier meal.
Popular Sandwiches And Their Prices
Some sandwiches are customer favorites. Here are the most ordered items and their typical prices.
- Italian: Salami, pepperoni, and provolone. Regular $7.99, Big $9.99
- Turkey Breast: Oven-roasted turkey with your choice of cheese. Regular $7.79, Big $9.79
- Meatball: Italian meatballs with marinara and provolone. Regular $8.29, Big $10.29
- Chicken Salad: Homestyle chicken salad with lettuce and tomato. Regular $7.49, Big $9.49
- Wreck: A mix of salami, roast beef, turkey, and ham. Regular $8.49, Big $10.49
The Wreck is the most popular sandwich on the menu. It combines four meats and two cheeses for a bold flavor. If you are hungry, this is a solid pick.
Salads And Soups
Potbelly offers a few salads for those watching carbs. They also have soup options that change seasonally.
- Garden Salad: $6.99
- Caesar Salad: $7.49
- Chicken Caesar Salad: $8.49
- Cup of Soup: $3.99
- Bowl of Soup: $5.49
You can add a protein like chicken or steak to any salad for an extra $1.50 to $2.00. The soup flavors rotate, but common options include tomato basil, chicken noodle, and broccoli cheddar.
Sides And Extras
No meal is complete without a side. Potbelly has a few classic options.
- Potbelly Chips: $1.99
- Apple Slices: $1.49
- Cookie: $1.79
- Brownie: $2.29
- Pickle Spear: $0.99
You can also add extra meat, cheese, or avocado to any sandwich. Extra meat or cheese costs about $1.50. Avocado is $1.00 extra.
Drinks And Shakes
Potbelly is famous for its hand-dipped shakes. They also have standard soft drinks and bottled beverages.
- Hand-Dipped Shake (Regular): $4.99
- Hand-Dipped Shake (Large): $5.99
- Soft Drink (Small): $1.99
- Soft Drink (Medium): $2.29
- Soft Drink (Large): $2.59
- Bottled Water: $1.79
- Milk: $2.29
Shake flavors include vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and seasonal specials. They are thick and creamy, made with real ice cream.
Breakfast Menu At Potbelly
Potbelly also serves breakfast at select locations. The breakfast menu is available until 11:00 AM. It includes breakfast sandwiches, oatmeal, and coffee.
- Breakfast Sandwich (Egg and Cheese): $4.49
- Breakfast Sandwich (With Meat): $5.49
- Oatmeal: $3.99
- Bagel with Cream Cheese: $2.99
- Coffee (Small): $1.99
- Coffee (Medium): $2.49
Breakfast sandwiches come on your choice of bread, including croissants, bagels, or flatbread. Meat options include bacon, sausage, or ham.
Breakfast Combos
You can save a little by ordering a combo. A breakfast sandwich with coffee and a side costs about $7.49.
- Choose your breakfast sandwich.
- Add a small coffee.
- Pick a side like chips or fruit.
- Pay the combo price.
This is a good deal if you want a full breakfast without ordering everything separately.
Catering Menu And Group Pricing
Potbelly offers catering for offices, parties, and events. The catering menu includes sandwich platters, salad bowls, and cookie trays.
- Sandwich Platter (Serves 10-12): $89.99
- Salad Platter (Serves 8-10): $59.99
- Cookie Tray (24 Cookies): $24.99
- Brownie Tray (12 Brownies): $19.99
- Soup Tureen (Serves 8-10): $44.99
Catering orders must be placed at least 24 hours in advance. You can customize the sandwich platter with your choice of meats and breads.
How To Order Catering
Ordering catering from Potbelly is simple. Follow these steps.
- Visit the Potbelly website or call your local store.
- Select the catering tab.
- Choose your platters and sides.
- Set a pickup time.
- Pay online or at the store.
They also offer delivery for catering orders over a certain amount, usually $100 or more. Check with your local store for details.
Potbelly Rewards And Discounts
Potbelly has a loyalty program called Potbelly Perks. You earn points for every dollar you spend. Points can be redeemed for free sandwiches, shakes, and other items.
- Sign Up Bonus: 200 points after your first purchase.
- Points Earned: 10 points per dollar spent.
- Free Sandwich: 500 points.
- Free Shake: 300 points.
- Free Cookie: 100 points.
You can also find coupons and special offers in the app. Sometimes they offer a free cookie with any purchase or a discount on your birthday.
How To Save Money At Potbelly
If you want to keep your meal under $10, here are a few tips.
- Order a regular-sized sandwich instead of a Big.
- Skip the drink and bring your own water.
- Share a cookie or brownie with a friend.
- Use the app to find digital coupons.
- Sign up for Potbelly Perks to earn free food.
These small changes can save you $2 to $4 per visit. Over time, that adds up.
Nutritional Information And Dietary Options
Potbelly provides nutritional info for all menu items. You can find it on their website or ask in-store. They also have options for different dietary needs.
- Gluten-Free: They offer gluten-free bread for an extra $1.00.
- Low-Carb: You can get any sandwich as a lettuce wrap or salad.
- Vegetarian: The Garden Salad and Veggie Sandwich are good choices.
- Vegan: The Veggie Sandwich without cheese is vegan-friendly.
Most sandwiches have between 400 and 700 calories. The Big sandwiches can go up to 1,000 calories or more. If you are counting calories, stick with the regular size and load up on veggies.
Allergen Information
Potbelly lists common allergens for each menu item. They use wheat, dairy, soy, and eggs in many of their products. If you have a serious allergy, talk to the manager before ordering.
- Wheat/Gluten: Present in all breads and most cookies.
- Dairy: Present in cheese, shakes, and some soups.
- Soy: Present in some dressings and sauces.
- Eggs: Present in cookies and some breads.
They do not use peanuts or tree nuts in their kitchens, but cross-contamination is possible. Always inform the staff of your allergies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the cheapest item on the Potbelly menu?
The cheapest item is usually a cup of soup for $3.99 or a pickle spear for $0.99. A regular sandwich starts around $7.49.
Does Potbelly have a secret menu?
There is no official secret menu, but you can customize any sandwich. Ask for the “Wreck” with extra meat or a “Skinny” version with no bread.
Can I get a Potbelly sandwich without bread?
Yes, you can order any sandwich as a lettuce wrap or a salad. There is no extra charge for this substitution.
Does Potbelly offer military or student discounts?
Some locations offer a 10% military discount with valid ID. Student discounts are rare but sometimes available near college campuses. Ask at your local store.
How often does Potbelly change its menu?
Potbelly introduces seasonal items a few times a year. The core menu stays the same, but limited-time sandwiches and shakes appear in summer and fall.
Final Tips For Ordering
When you visit Potbelly, take a moment to look at the board. The prices are clearly listed. If you are ordering for a group, consider the catering platters for better value.
Remember that the Potbelly menu with prices can vary by location. A sandwich that costs $7.99 in one city might be $8.49 in another. Always confirm before you pay.
If you are in a hurry, use the Potbelly app to order ahead. You can skip the line and grab your food quickly. The app also shows the exact prices for your local store.
One more thing: the cookies are worth the extra dollar. They are baked fresh and come in chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and sugar. Get one with your meal for a sweet finish.
Potbelly is a solid choice for a quick, tasty meal that wont break the bank. With this guide, you know exactly what to expect from the Potbelly menu with prices. Go ahead and treat yourself to a toasted sandwich and a shake. You have earned it.